For several days after Dday I was clinging desperately to 1) but lately I have become more and more convinced that she is just not going to be there with me, and as you said I cannot do that by myself. So now I am trying to detach, let go and accept that path 2) is the one I'll have to take.
Great. So you have a fairly logical view that these are your two paths, and (1) isn't looking too good for you right now. At least not the way things are currently going.
You are right to try to detach. There is something called the "180." Have you read about it? Advice: you really should. It is *the* tool a BS has. Please do everything in your power to trust this. When you inevitably have the following questions: 1) won't this push my wife further away? and 2) isn't this being dishonest, the opposite of what I want to be?, check in here for more guidance.
All of us have seen the following truths on SI, over and over and over, when BS's are dealing with WS's still actively in an affair:
1) If the BS does the 180--really works at it--they begin to find the tables turning in their favor within 24-72 hours. Reconciliation or Divorce are still options.
2) If the BS *doesn't do* the 180--either refuses (fails to believe it's the right strategy) or fails (constantly breaks 180 behaviors)--they only find failure and suffering. Rugsweeping (we're currently calling it Option 3) or Divorce are the only options.
But I see that path a bit more nuanced: it's about separation at first, not divorce, at least for now, until the children are out of college etc.
This is fine, sure. Most people have a separation before the divorce is finalized. In fact, as you know, the divorce process lasts a minimum of several months and often goes on for years.
Just tuck this little nugget of wisdom away somewhere in your brain for now: *filing* for divorce is not the same as *getting* a divorce.
I know you're not mentally at that point yet. But just begin opening up to the idea that the planning and process is not the same as the thing itself.
We can have a civilized discussion about that, about co-parenting etc. and her still supporting the house and the kids while she moves out (with or without him, doesn't really matter). She already accepted that as the likely possibility moving forward.
I'm only asking for clarity, for both me and you: how can you be so sure you can have this "civilized" discussion? If you mean "civilized" in the sense that it can be a calm and politely-worded discussion, then yes, maybe.
But I want to caution you here: your wife is still in contact with this man, her lover, and they are making plans that you don't know about. I'm telling you this as a "friend" you've never met but who truly understands how this works and who has a deep hope that you can trust on some level that your situation is similar to thousands of others.
You have been the victim of a deep network of manipulation, and that hasn't stopped yet. Any "civilized" conversation you have (or are currently having) will still be permeated with lies, half-truths, subtle blame-shifting, and manipulation. She may not even be conscious to the fact that she's doing it, but these things will be happening. This means you need to be on your A-game and take all that she says with a grain of salt. Everything.
She says she'll move to an apartment and still send you money for half the mortgage? Do not take her at her word unless you have a legal contract. She says she's cut off contact with AP for now? Recognize that she has likely just found a stealthier way to stay in contact with him. She says she's running out to the store, or to her office? Recognize that she is likely back in a parking-lot "meeting" with her affair partner.
It is important that you're vigilant with your awareness, if for no other reason than so you can make sound, clearly-informed decisions for yourself and your children moving forward.
Path 3) is an abomination, I do not want that. I won't put it past her to attempt that, as I see she is still very wary and ashamed of the idea of telling our families and friends about the affair, so she might want to go back to how things were, to keep the appearances etc. -- but no, I and the children discussed that, it's either path 1) or path 2) (and 2) meaning she leaves the house).
I agree. Path (3) is unacceptable for any married man. Something needs to change.
For now, still being in covid lockdown we are not pushing her to pick either of these paths, but we'll have a very serious discussion when this is over.
Here, I have some serious concerns for you and your well-being. The more time you give this/her, the more things will crumble around you.
It is a *very* common (and faulty) BS mindset that somehow it is up to the WS to make a "choice." This is suicide by lack of action.
You seem like a rational, intelligent guy. So let me ask you if the following bolded statement rings true as something you could reasonably communicate to your wife, or whether you see flaws in it that would need correction:
"WW, I understand that you are struggling to make a decision about whether to choose me, your husband, or AP, your boyfriend. I can see it's a very difficult choice for you. However, after deep reflection, I've realized something incredibly important that, whether I like it or not, is going to affect how I move forward from here: I am currently treating you as a priority (as, indeed, a wife *should* be to a husband), and you are merely treating me as an option. One of two choices.
I have also realized that while I am waiting for you to thoroughly weigh these two "options" before you, I am also engaged in something that I find reprehensible and personally unworkable: *sharing* my wife. I cannot allow that for one minute longer, and I regret that I have allowed it for as long as I have.
I have come to realize that the one thing I thought would be the worst thing possible in my marriage--losing my wife--is nothing compared to the reality of sharing her.
These things--sharing you and being an option to you--are unacceptable to me as a husband, a father, and a man. As sad and difficult as it is, I have realized that I cannot continue to exist in a situation where I am an option to my wife--the one person I am supposed to be able to trust and rely on--and while she continues to have a boyfriend. So while you are weighing your options, I have no choice but to proceed with the divorce process.
I am going another way, for both me and my family. I believe we can do this rationally and equitably in a way that will result in fairness and stability in the end. This is especially important to me as a father. To be clear: I am not happy that I have to take this path, but there is no other rational choice before me. I cannot fix this marriage by myself, and I cannot logically (or emotionally) stay in limbo while you try to see if you can work things out with AP, long for him, desire him, communicate with him in a romantic way, and so on.
So this is the path I'm taking, as I have no other choice. You are now free to do whatever you please. I will not check up on you, I will not ask you who you are seeing, I will not ask you about AP. I will be focusing on the divorce process and on our children.
If something changes for you down the road, then I will consider stopping the divorce process and attempting a reconciliation with you. By that point, it may be too late. That has yet to be seen."
What do you think? Is this a reasonable approach? If not, in what ways does it concern you? What, if anything, about the words or process here doesn't seem like it will work for you?
~
There is another thing that, like it or not, will not go away: the other betrayed spouse.
One of the most common things seen here on SI is the following process:
1) BS balks at telling OBS because it's "not my business" or "I don't want to ruin two marriages" or "I don't want to hurt him/her" or "I think s/he already knows" or "I'm scared" and on and on.
2) BS eventually realizes that nothing changes as long as the affair is allowed to remain in the dark.
3) BS eventually (often reluctantly) informs the OBS.
4) BS comes back here to SI and tells us all how it was the ABSOLUTE BEST THING they could have done and that they wish they had listened to the advice here and done it sooner.
Check around for threads where this has happened. There are many.
Only you can make your choices for your life. But know this: affairs thrive in secrecy.
Even if the moral argument doesn't sway you, know that telling the OBS is the #1 affair-killing tool that exists in the world of infidelity.
Also know this: *not* telling the OBS is not a smart "wait and see" approach. It may feel like a nuclear option that will somehow hurt you or ruin your chances at a positive outcome, but that is never the case.
Tell the OBS, and this affair can be over quite quickly and you can be in a better position to make clear decisions and take rational steps forward. You may even find that option (1) becomes viable.
~
Please keep posting. Truly curious to hear your thoughts on what I've outlined above.
[This message edited by Okokok at 7:12 AM, May 3rd (Sunday)]