36,
Gently here.
I know you are dealing with a horrible situation and you are doing as well as can be expected.
I get that in your mind, you are trying to reconcile because you are often thinking about your wife of 36 years rather than the monster she has been for the last 2 months. However, I am sure that the monster of the last 2 months has caused irreparable damage to what you two built up over 36 years.
Keep in mind that it is not your job to fix what has happened, it's hers. It's also not your job to figure out what happened, it's hers.
The bigger questions are
1) Can you ever get over it. If you can't, don't reconcile. Think 10 years, 5 years, 3 years down the line and project.
2) At any point over your 36 years, reflecting back, do you think she may have done this before ?
3) How do you get over her being infatuated so much that she wanted you dead ?
4) Part of the equation is what she did for the 13 days she was out of the house while you were suffering. Do you have any idea ?
5) Even if you take her back, you will have difficulties trying to figure out how you measure up to the OM sexually and what she is thinking about when you two do have sexual relations in the future. Trust me, this happened with me. Are you ready for that ?
6) Her lack of guilt and remorse and her arrogant attitude reflects on her character. If she is potentially R material, she needs to be brought to her knees.
I am not the most pro-R person and couldn't in your case.
Please, moving forward, keep in mind that while you have kids, any decisions from here on out are yours and yours alone. So often, I see the WW try to turn the kids against the betrayed. I see kids trying to keep the parents together even at the detriment of the betrayed. There are other ways for them to support the parents without forcing this.
Have you kept in mind what is really in this for you to stay ? Positives vs negatives ?
Here are my suggestions
1) 180, people say this is to work on you and it really is. Yes there are other benefits of it. You find out really fast what the WW's intentions are and it is a good way to put the pressure on them to leave due to the discomfort and BTW, YOU NEED TO GET HER OUT. As another poster said, she is a danger to you now and is still in the affair, despite what she is saying.
2) Protect your assets legally. Hire a good attorney and protect what you can. Ensure you have enough for a good divorce attorney.
3) Beware of the dreaded false DV order. Your wife may see it all falling apart and may try to lie and get desperate to keep her lifestyle afloat. She has already lied before. Could you imagine you out of the house and this guy with your wife in your house ? Don't let that be you !!
4) Expose this cult that they have. Expose them all to their spouses. Exposure helps these people's spouses realize what is happening and let's them stop it, makes them safe and blows up this guys world and maybe some of theirs and while many here say to expose to end the affairs, I have no hesitation to expose to damage serial cheaters and AP's. Holy crap, a Christian Social Work organization behaving a s a brothel is mind shattering.
5) Get that attorney consultation. Hire a good one.
6) I like what you did by instilling an immediate consequence by taking her off of life insurance. Now she's scared and will try to get back on it. Keep her scared.
7) You need to prepare for the 'wolf in waiting' trap. She's sticking around and may still be plotting against you. Do you have any VARs installed ? PI hired ? Lawyers informed ?
8) When that guy came by and thought he could entice you guys into a threesome, did he do this thinking that she was single ? Did she set that up ? Or is he that brazen ?
On a final note, this OM is a complete predator. I am guessing your wife is about 56-60 years old. Players like this guy usually go for younger prey so this guy is using your wife to get into your pocket. This in no way shape or form is critical of your wife's appearance as we all feel that our wives are enormously attractive. It is just reality and this is more the reason to batten down the finances and get her out. Being cheated on is bad enough and the mind movies you have I would be having too and it would be ripping me apart. Being set up for this is horribly painful too