While trying to avoid broad generalizations, I recall studies exploring how "women" are often perceived as "the more compassionate gender," so "compassionate" role expectations might be a socially acquired response we expect of ourselves, and others expect of us.
And when we feel compassion, yet we don't believe we're wearing some sign that says "Please walk all over me," such an approach may put us, the proximal victim of the SA, the victim with the most invested, and thus the most to lose, into a posture or position inadequate to truly protect ourselves. We might not even perceive this, ourselves. Our warning sign would remain unread if the other party believed walking all over us went with the assigned role they'd slotted us into. To disordered people, thinking we are more compassionate can equal their thinking we are more tolerant of victimization.
This really spoke to me. I have so much compassion for those who are staying with their SA spouse. If I had not caught XH in bed with another woman, then had him scream at me that I was crazy for thinking that he still wanted to be with me, I likely would have been that person who stayed forever.
I also have compassion for any SA. Even if they had no childhood trauma (which the research shows is unlikely), living their lives in such a depraved way has to be painful. The shame itself is enough to eat you alive. And for those who did live through CSA, or any other trauma that may have led to this type of behavior in adulthood, well that is a pain I would not wish on anyone either. And yet, here they are, inflicting pain on those they supposedly love.
I had committed myself to being compassionate forever, because of the vows I took. My personalized vows, AFTER I already knew about the SA, were that I would choose him, every day. I had his ring inscribed with, "I choose you, always." And I did. Every day that I stayed was a choice. Some days were good, some great, some bad, some terrible. But each evening, I kissed him good night and said "I love you". Each morning, I kissed him before he left for work and said the same thing. No matter how good or bad things were, that was the one constant. I love you, and I'm choosing you.
But that was part of the role I had chosen, the "compassionate one." He knew I had chosen it too. Whenever he would cross a boundary and I would compromise on it, he would say, "See, you're so sweet to me." The unspoken caveat to that statement is, "...even though you have no reason to be." If I didn't want to have sex that night, but he kept coming and rubbing me all over with his hands? Well, my compromise was to let him grab my ass, not rub it. The rubbing kept me awake, but I told myself, compromise is the hallmark of any good relationship, and if he just held it, well I could fall asleep to that. And he would whisper in my ear, "Aww, you're so sweet to me for letting me do that."
He couldn't stop masturbating with my lacy underwear? Well, I went out and bought rolls of lace from Joann's so that he would have an alternative. I was "so sweet" then too. A real adult could have figured that solution out for himself. But clearly I was so much better at problem solving than him, he just needed the extra help, and spouses are supposed to help each other, right? Until he used it all up, didn't go buy anymore, then went right back to using my underwear. I had handed him a solution on a silver platter. But it didn't matter.
He couldn't stop leaving the underwear in random places (couch cushions, corner of the shower) getting mildewed and staining things? Well no matter how many times I asked for him to just keep them clean, he never would. So I, with my seemingly infinite compassion, resigned myself to the fact that he just wasn't good at remembering that stuff. That he was so ashamed of the behavior, that I should prove to him that he doesn't need to be ashamed. So I would wash them for him. Surely that would make him see that he could be vulnerable and open with me? But it didn't.
In those moments, his insatiable need was more important than my right to privacy, personal property or bodily autonomy. And in the moments after I would discover it, and he would lie through his teeth, coming up with excuse after excuse - in those moments, his need to bury his shame was more important than betraying my trust. My own peace of mind, my ability to trust the facts that were right in front of me, were not worth giving up on the gaslighting. Because the feel bads he got from telling the truth were just so much worse than the gut wrenching, mind bending pain I felt when my spouse, the person I'm supposed to trust most in the world, was not only telling me that the sky was purple, but that I was crazy for insisting otherwise.
I have numerous love notes from him, telling me that his stubbornness is like a rock, and my patience is like a stream, slowly wearing him down. Or that he has so many walls, but I have had the patience to slowly tear them down. The thing is, it wasn't my job to wear him or tear him down. I should have seen his being open and vulnerable with me as a requirement for a good and healthy relationship, not something that I had to earn by showing him how hard I would work for it. What would have been enough to prove that he could be open with me? Moving in with him? Marrying him? Raising his children as my own? Making him and his daughters lunch every day? Using my credit cards to cover his expenses because he was "so broke" even though he made more money than me? Buying him new clothes because he wanted to look nice for work, but he couldn't afford it? Trying to have a baby with him? Planning every vacation we ever took, every party we ever threw, because he wanted these things, but he just wasn't a "planner"? Letting him know, everyday, in words, but also in actions - big and small - how much I loved him? Oh wait, I did all of those things. Nothing was ever going to be enough.
And these were not things that I did because I thought he would "owe" me something in return. There was no passive aggressive ulterior motive. No tit for tat, no quid pro quo. I did these things because I loved him, and I wanted him to be happy. If he told me something was making him unhappy, I did my damndest to fix it. I'm sure each of us could write such a list. Of all of the things that we did for them out of love and also compassion. The only thing I asked for in return was love, loyalty, and a commitment to try just as hard as I did. But he didn't try nearly as hard. He wanted a lover, a mother, and a professor in Adulting 101, but he reserved the right to resent me if I ever took on any of those roles too fervently. I was constantly scrambling to fill each role, just well enough so that he would appreciate it, but just poorly enough that I wouldn't be perceived as "controlling." Trying to strike that balance every day is fucking exhausting.
You know, as if you were nothing but a thing. A glass that someone unwittingly knocked off a table as they were walking by. Oops. Didn't see you there while I was fucking whores. My bad.
I am not here as a supporting role in anyone else's life. I am here to live my life. I absolutely refuse to be mere "collateral damage". Every one of us here is far more valuable than a mere side-character in someone else's drama. The focus should be on the actual victims. If the perpetrators want to become decent human beings, they can google help for that as easily as they googled Backpages or Craigslist. They don't require my compassion to do so. They require growing the fuck up and taking responsibility for what they have become before traumatizing their spouses.
That really says it all. The entitlement, the selfishness. When they do all of these terrible things, they are only thinking of themselves. We then get caught up in also thinking about them - how can we fix them, heal them? So all of the focus is on the SA - their trauma, their shame, their pain. When will we be worth focusing on? When we put our foot down and demand it.
You know what he said when I caught them? When I begged, "Please, I'm your wife, you at least owe me an explanation!" He screamed, "I don't owe you shit!" Well then, I don't owe him another ounce of my compassion. That is better spent on myself.