I don't want to R not because it is not possible but because I don't have what it takes to do reconcile.
AH, I think you should drop this kind of thinking from your approach here. It's not about having "what it takes." It's not like people who reconcile are special saints. There's nothing wrong with reconciling, but there's nothing wrong with divorcing either.
And look, a LOT has to go right for reconciliation truly to work. Most of what has to go right puts the onus on the wayward spouse, not the betrayed. We do read here about kind, introspective waywards who have managed to step outside themselves and really heal the marriage. It does happen. But frankly, it doesn't seem to happen often enough.
So I would stop putting this pressure on myself if I were in your shoes. What you have is "what it takes" to be successful in life. Period. You don't need to put any more burden on yourself than that.
You did nothing here. She did everything. And she continues to do it. You can feel bad for her that she put herself in this position. That's empathy. Fine. But you're not required to take the mantle of her sin as a scapegoat.
The silly bromide that gets thrown around here far too casually is 100 percent of the cheating is on her, but that the marriage problems are shared 50/50. In my opinion, most of the time that turns out not to be true on closer examination. Most of the time it turns out the wayward spouse has been intellectually and emotionally lazy and toxic for some period of time prior to the betrayal, often for years before the betrayal. The faithful spouse has been struggling along in a deteriorating situation.
The wayward spouse often began intentionally sabotaging what was a good marriage before they decided to kill it off with adultery.
And that certainly is the case with your situation.
Why do they do it? I don't think we need to spend a great deal of time trying to figure that out. Because they are selfish people. They wanted it, they sought it, they found an opportunity and took it, they liked it, and they thought they could manage it without being caught. It's really not a lot more complicated than that.
In a divorce, you step away from the primary source of your pain, the actual wayward spouse who did this to you. It's often said that in reconciliation, you have to be willing to belly up and eat a shit sandwich.
But what if your spouse IS the shit sandwich?
You can start healing much faster by simply choosing NOT to shackle yourself to pain, by choosing to stop enabling or propping up a toxic crazymaker, and we see it ALL THE TIME on SI and other places. Those who divorce and move on quickly seem to heal much faster.
Now look, I'm someone who lingered in limbo for nearly four years before telling my WW I was done. That just happened within the past two weeks, so I can't tell you how I'll feel a year from now. But I can report to you that I feel better and lighter and more clear-headed the past two weeks than I've felt in nearly four years.
Is my wife a sociopath? Is she -- to use the term recently thrown around by those who seem to think people like me like to pile on WW's -- a witch? Decidedly no. She's confounding and her actions have been confounding and painful and heartbreaking. But it's not my job to fix her.
In the rare circumstance that a wayward spouse "gets it" -- and has NOT started to do more toxic damage with blameshifting, trickle truth, rationalizations, breaking NC and calling their boyfriend, trying to manipulate with tissue-thin appeals to Jesus and the like -- you can carefully consider reconciliation.
But it's clear that reconciliation is a huge gamble.
People don't like to talk about the fact that divorce just isn't as big of a gamble. It just isn't. You're know what you're getting -- and part of what you're getting is no longer having to deal with a personality, a person, that willfully betrayed you and hurt you. You deal with them a little bit, but most of your days you can be separate from them.
You're on the right path, AH. Stay on it and jettison the unnecessary guilt that says you're somehow lesser than because you don't want to stick around for the continuing shitshow of the reality TV show/ car wreck /dumpster fire that your wife has created for herself.