kgcolonel - I only recently discovered the Love Languages, and I so wish I had learned of them sooner! BH's is strongly Acts of Service. Mine are Words of Affirmation and Physical Touch. I have not read the book yet, but I'm on the waitlist for it at the library. I think my ignorance of his love language is a large part of what made me not appreciate what I had in our relationship, and what made me susceptible to straying (that, and a host of things that were broken within me to begin with).
Thank you for your support and the thoughtful input. I'm certain he is struggling with quite a bit right now, and I am doing everything I can to not make it worse.
Hellfire - I'm still trying to figure out the answers to these questions -- I've asked them of myself at least 1000 times. I didn't make the first move, but it doesn't matter. I enabled him, and that's enough.
I haven't scheduled a polygraph -- it was offered as a part of my disclosure during MC, but BH doesn't believe in them.
WaitedWayTooLong - I appreciate your response. It's tough but fair. I have been minimizing things -- BH pointed it out to me a few days ago, and I've been making a concerted effort to not do so (mentally to myself, as well as when speaking to others). If you or anyone else encounters me doing it, please call me out and hold me accountable. I recognize this is something I need to address. I've been catching myself, but would appreciate the eagle eyes of some of the folks here, as well.
I am not keeping anything from BH -- I've told him everything I can recall. I also answer his questions honestly AND (more recently) to the fullest extent I can. I can't tell if he believes me (and why should he?), but he isn't challenging my answers as much anymore.
I appreciate the hope -- it's all I feel like I have, some days, so I can use as much as I can get.
Limboaz - I've been thinking a lot about my feelings for AP, lately, in response to some of the comments here. I should first mention that I am not terribly in touch with my feelings, in general, so I'm starting from a deficit. Forgive me if any of what I say comes off as remedial.
I had feelings for AP. I was in a very low place and he lifted me up. I felt unwanted, and he wanted me. I was depressed, but lightened by his optimism. Yes, I had feelings. But it was a mirage -- he wasn't who I thought he was, and what I felt wasn't what I thought it was. I thought it was love, in my fog-addled brain, but it was actually just a desperate attempt to feel validated. I'm planning to go into more detail on this, soon.
To clarify the timeline -- I don't remember exactly when all of this happened, but my rejection of BH was definitely well before the A. I believe BH's decision to no longer pursue sex with me was also before the A (by at least 6 months or so). The reason for the drop in bedroom activity was because of my deteriorating mental state, not because it was directed toward someone else. Truth be told, my enjoyment of sex has not been the same, since.
That being said, when AP came into the picture, I did carve out time for him. Far too much time. It threatened my job and it further handicapped my M. I feel sick when I think of all the hours I stole from BH to be with AP, especially after AP left my company. While I wouldn't say I shifted my primary loyalty, I was putting a lot of effort into the A, and it took a toll on me.
Thank you for the wish for luck - I hope there is something worth saving, after all the damage I did. I assure you, I've never wanted anything so badly as to prove to BH every day how much he means to me. But I'm working on letting go of that as a goal, because I can see how fear of the "negative" outcome is stifling my ability to give him what he needs...but I haven't managed to do so, yet.
FarsideJunky - The "mixed bag" has a few components.
Sex with AP lasted longer that it did with BH. AP was also more adventuresome - BH was not interested in exploring any "kinks", so our sex was very run-of-the-mill. I enjoyed the "adventure" of it, with AP. BH was my only sexual partner before this whole disaster, so there was a lot I hadn't experienced.
That being said, BH was larger than AP, and more attentive. He knew my body almost as well as I did. I never orgasmed with AP. That doesn't mean that I didn't enjoy myself, and honestly that end result got quite a bit harder with BH as well, ever since my libido took a nose dive. I've come to realize I was searching for a feeling of validation and being wanted...but because I had lost my confidence in myself, I also lost my capacity for sexual gratification.
I apologize if it doesn't make sense -- I've just started to spend any serious time thinking about it.
xhz700 - I think I've addressed this already, but it doesn't hurt to reiterate: Yes, you're absolutely right. I am that kind of person. I don't know how to process that information, yet, but it's undeniably true. I've been in IC for about a month, and every day more issues come up. I have a feeling it's going to take a long time before I can really internalize it, but I'm trying. I know I need to.
In regards to the "They want to" statement -- while I don't disagree, I do find it overly simplistic. When BH said something very similar to me last week, I told him I found that explanation insufficient and unacceptable, and I was not going to be satisfied with it. It's easy to say, because it's hurtful and true, but it's an explanation that doesn't actually explain anything. It doesn't provide any insight.
Sananman - Thank you for the response. It was constructive and thoughtful. I agree that I have lied to myself on countless occasions. But I think I was lying to myself within the A as much as any other time. (If it wasn't love, how could I justify what I was doing?) But I did have feelings for AP. I invested far too much time and effort into the A to make a case for otherwise.
Sex didn't really matter to me -- I went along with it because AP wanted it, and because I wanted to be wanted by him. But the void in me that I was trying to fill with AP wasn't physical - it was worse. I'm sure there was a part of me that liked the danger of it all, but I'm generally a very risk-adverse person, and so it wasn't as thrilling as it was anxiety-provoking.
I did it for the ego kibbles -- I was starving for ego kibbles. When the A started, I was in the throes of a crisis of confidence the likes of which I had never experienced before. AP made me feel good about myself, as long as I didn't think about what I was doing to BH (or could rationalize it away). I would do anything AP wanted me to, in order to keep the kibbles coming. It's disgusting to admit.
I'm not going to go into the state of the A in my head, before DDay. It doesn't matter if I wanted to end it or not, because the fact is that I didn't end it. Same thing with the invitation to our home - it doesn't matter if I intended for sex or not, because the fact is that it happened. Any discussion of intent on my part minimizes the actions that were taken, and I'm making an effort to stop doing that. However, I won't concede to intentions that I didn't have. I might have been fooling myself - that is absolutely possible - and if I realize that to be the case, I'll be the first to admit it.
I agree that I have a lot of work to do. My understanding is that most WS's don't show up here so soon after DDay, so I have a lot of ground to make up. There is absolutely some thrashing that I'm sure is uncomfortable for everyone. I appreciate that you've all stuck with me so far. I also appreciate the hopes for R - I'm not afraid of hard, or work, or time. I'd love to be given the chance, as I have no doubt it would be worth it.
NamasteGirl10 - Believe me, I know there are no guarantees. The truth is that the damage I did to my M might be terminal. I only meant that I didn't want to wait if it was absolutely not possible to R. BH was adamant that we were going to D, and I was looking for some advice about if I should take him at his word or if I should wait and see. In the words of Bon Jovi -- I'm living on a prayer.
skerzoid - While I disagree with your assessment of it being about lust, I appreciate the input and perspective. I'm not sure if my responses above shed any more light on the situation, but if they fail to address your questions please let me know.
Keeping the letters was incredibly stupid. I can't believe I did it, although I am oddly glad I did, because BH deserved to see them. I deleted so much of the evidence of the A, that they are pretty much all he has. They also forced me to admit everything, which I can't in good faith say I would have done otherwise, out of fear of the consequences.
I fear you may be right about all of the damage I've done. I'm doing my best to support his healing, but I can tell he's growing impatient with me. If I knew for sure what would be best for him, I'd do it in a heartbeat...
harrybrown - Thank you - these questions are thought-provoking and I agree that many of my decisions were "lousy". You're kinder than I would be. When I look back at all of the things I did, and all of the choices I made, I can't believe it. I'm doing everything I can to help BH. He deserves 10x the amount of effort I put into the A. He's certainly more than 10x the man AP was. Hell, he's 10x the person I am, too. It kills me that I did this to him - that I took advantage of his love and trust for me this way. He was so good to me, and I didn't see it. I didn't appreciate everything he did for me, all the times he was there for me, all the ways he accommodated me...it's thoughts of those that makes me cry, most often. The kindness he showed me, consistently, and which I paid back with such cruelty.
MidnightRun - I can't say I'm "fully prepared" but I'm braced for the likely eventuality and I appreciate the words of preparation. It's not the outcome I want, but if BH determines that's the path that will make him happiest, that's what I want for him. I still hope he doesn't make that determination, but I can't in any way hold it against him if he does.
xhz700 - You're right, I didn't care - at least, certainly not enough. And you're right, I need to adjust how I see myself. And lastly, you're right, I need to get over the outcome. I'm attempting the last 2, but they are challenging for me. Some days are better than others.
FreeAsABird - I suppose the answer depends. I didn't know about the dating sites until after NC was established, but I did know AP had started seeing another woman - as of a couple of weeks before DDay. He later told his BW the the woman was made up to make me upset, so I'm not sure if she actually exists or not.
Akheron - I have attempted to retrieve them, but AP and I did not correspond much over text. My cell phone provider doesn't keep deleted texts past 30 days, and I have switched phones multiple times over the past year (due to hardware issues, not A-related). I also checked if there were a way to retrieve Instagram messages, but they appear to be deleted instantly. I searched the internet for ways to retrieve them, and even tried downloading some tools to help, but they were just spam.
LongSadStory1952 - You're right - I didn't end it. What I thought or intended or might have done is inconsequential. I know BH thinks I've been minimizing, and I'm attempting to stop that. At this point, I'm just going to stop discussing intent altogether, because it only seems to make people upset. I can't prove it one way or the other, and it doesn't matter one way or the other, anyway. I am going to continue thinking about it, because I think it is important when it comes to "why", but I'm going to stop talking about it.
HardyRose - Yes, I'm aware of how this thread has devolved. I don't really have interest in the semantics and details, but do feel compelled to address questions as they are asked of me.
I think I've already mentioned some of this, but in regards to making myself safe, I'm in IC, I am journaling, I'm here, I'm focusing on living honestly and vulnerably, I'm practicing forgiveness, I'm planning to start meditating for mindfulness, I'm seeking out interactions with positive people, I'm reinforcing a work-life balance, and I'm attempting to show daily commitment to my BH and my M through acts of service.
As for why I had an A, I'm in IC, I'm journaling, and I'm here, all with the goal of introspection and self-reflection.
If there is more I can be doing, I would love to know. I often feel like what I'm doing isn't enough.
Sassylee - This has been challenging, but BH needed the support. I cringe myself sometimes when he tells me some of the responses he gets on his JFO thread (from what I can tell, I'm a monster over there), but if he feels it is helping him then he has my full support to stay. I agree that it is difficult to be open when the other could be reading, but it's an exercise in trust. I trust BH more than anyone in the world. If he says he won't read, he won't. And while the curiosity might kill me, I am in a position where I can't afford a single breach. I don't know if BH believes I'm not reading -- I think he does. He has access to my history, and so I stay out of JFO altogether, to be safe. I need to do this right by him, and I think he knows that.
I have thought about adding the stop sign several times, but the truth of the matter is that I really value the BS perspective. Even if they are a little overzealous with their 2x4's, and I have to take a break from here for a little while to lick my wounds from time to time, it's important feedback. BH isn't very vocal with me about how he's feeling, and so the pain and passion in some of their responses can help me better understand what he's going through.
FarsideJunky - I am not familiar with the idea of toxic shame, but I can see how it fits my situation. I was always very preoccupied with appearances. I was competitive, judgmental, and unwilling to show vulnerability. Those things built in me a framework of deception and bitterness that I need to dismantle. I'm working on it, and have felt some changes from it already. There is certainly more work to go, though.
Booyah - BH and I are not close with our neighbors, so I doubt any of them knew he was out of town. But as I mentioned above, I don't believe discussions of intent are productive. I'm not interested in minimizing my behavior, and so it doesn't matter if I did or didn't intend to. Either way, it happened.
GoldenR - Feelings are slippery things. On the one hand, there's what I wrote in that letter, and what I said in the voicemail on DDay. On the other, there's how I felt seeing AP waiting for me in the garage before work after DDay. Or hearing his voice on my voicemail last week. The evidence from within the A shows one thing. The evidence now shows another. BH says if I say one word to AP, we're over. No problem - I have no desire to ever speak to AP again, anyway. On the other hand, BH is simply talking to me less and I feel painful isolation and missing him. Whatever I thought I felt for AP went up in smoke the second it was stress-tested.
I'm not sure I said I never had feelings for AP. I know I don't now, and I know that the feelings I had were baseless. But yes, I had them. It's hard to explain them without first understanding the "why", though. I'm trying to work on them in tandem, but it's slow progress.
Limboaz - Yes, AP was absolutely a narcissist. He is the most self-absorbed person I have ever met. But yes, the fog was there. It made me feel special that he seemed to be taking some time away from thinking about himself to think about me, instead. Now I see that it was all a facade. As selfish as I knew he was, he was actually even more so. For him, it was all about the power. The power over me, and to insert himself into my life (thereby the power over BH as well). He destroys everything he touches.
SorrowfulMoon - You're correct that no effort to continue the A occurred after DDay. You're also correct that I have made many mistakes, and will certainly make many more. I pray that they are overshadowed by my proper choices. Thank you for your wishes of luck and support to us.
M1965 - These are interesting questions and I agree that I need a goalpost to aim toward. Much of what I've been concerned with so far has been what I don't want to be/do, but the things I do want have been more productive. It is far easier to make progress toward what to be vs what not to be. Part of the daily check-ins that we have been doing as a part of MC (which I personally think have been valuable to us, although I hear JFO has different opinions) have been a disclosure of any "incidents" or "threats" to the M that might have happened that day. It's been extremely helpful for me, because it makes me actually think about if anything happened, and share it with BH. What got me into trouble was the not thinking about it, and not sharing things that may have happened with BH.
And no, cheating was absolutely not worth it.
Skerzoid - I don't believe you were cruel to me. Perhaps a bit enthusiastic to put me in my place, but not cruel. I have gotten myself into therapy and have so far found it to be very helpful. I foresee keeping it in my life in some regular cadence forever, as a way to keep myself aware and mindful of my shortcomings. I'm very sorry to hear about what happened to you in your childhood, and am heartened to hear that you overcame it. I, too, hope to find my "why" and incapacitate it. Thank you for the wishes of luck, and I appreciate the support.