Bahama
Some random thoughts about your situation:
Reconciliation is possible. This site is proof of it. But it’s a tough and hard thing to do. It requires total commitment and a very clear decision from both parties that you are dedicating the REST of your time together to creating the BEST relationship possible. It goes way beyond reconciling from the affair.
I venture that at least a third of those that post here and claim to be in reconciliation aren’t. True R is where you are unafraid to mention ANYTHING to your spouse and your spouse is willing to discuss the issue and reach a resolution you are both content with and are both 100% willing to see through. It hasn’t got anything to do with control, punishment, revenge but everything to do with communications, acceptance, goals and togetherness.
Of course, right now – this shortly after the decision to R – you two are nowhere near it. But you probably – like 99% of those that decide to reconcile – thought that simply deciding to R would get you half way there.
I have often used this comparison (old-timers would maybe say too often…):
Imagine you live a content but totally unhealthy lifestyle. You eat deep-fried for all meals, don’t exercise, drink coffee by the gallons, drink too much alcohol, live paycheck to paycheck, smoke… Then one day while arguing with your boss about a missed deadline you have a cardiac arrest…
Wake up in ER where you are sternly told that if you don’t make changes you are doomed for a repeat.
This is where your marriage is. Now – I’m not assigning ANY blame to you for your WW decision to cheat. But your marriage might have been unhealthy, if not for any other reason that your wife was unhealthy in the marriage.
You decide to change your life. You get a lecture on nutrition and buy all the healthy-eating books. You contact a personal trainer, sign up to a gym and go buy all the quick-dry clothes and the go-faster sneakers. You listen to the Dave Ramsey podcast to organize your finances and get the best time-management app for your phone.
All of this is the same as DECIDING to reconcile.
First time you eat baked cauliflower with soya cheese… You are going to miss deep-fried chicken. That glass of water won’t tickle your throat like a Dr. Pepper… After that first 3 mile run you won’t be feeling healthy… That gym-membership card won’t improve your health just waiting in your wallet… You will feel pain when you fight the urge for a smoke… Those sneakers don’t burn calories in the closet… That personal trainer isn’t doing the exercise for you…
Heck… even if you do stick to a program then the results won’t be coming in too early. That marathon you wanted to run? Won’t make it for maybe the first 2 years. Benching 200 might take you a year. You might relapse couple of times on the smoking…
It’s small, minor improvements over a very long period.
Add to the equation that your wife must be along too. If she’s sneaking French-fries on her plate while you are having boiled fish with carrots, or if she sits down at a bench with a Marlboro and a Mimosa and waits for you to run the laps…
If you stick to the program, then 2-3-4 years down the line you might reflect on your results. You might realize you are in better shape – physically and mentally – than ever before. You might also realize that you can still make improvements. Your wants and urges to go back to your old lifestyle will be less, weaker and fewer.
This is reconciliation in a nutshell. It’s a long-term process of CHANGE for improvement. Just like the cardiac arrest was the catalyst for change in the above, the affair is the catalyst for change in the marriage. But… just like you could have decided to change your life WITHOUT the cardiac arrest, so could you have based your marriage on better grounds.
The sex issue:
Bahama – by the time your WW could decide if the A sex was better or if she should base her affair on the sex… It was too late. It’s like a bank-robber suggesting it wasn’t a robbery since he only got 1k bucks out of it rather than the expected 10k. She DID NOT have the affair because the sex was better. She would NOT have quit had OM had ED or not preformed or been a selfish lover. By the time of first physical contact it was too late – it was an affair. Same applies to any comparison to the OM – by the time your wife had the basis to build a comparison it was too late.
I personally think infidelity is NEVER about the sex. It’s all about POWER. Undeniably power is a great aphrodisiac, but I think the driving force is the sense of I CAN, I have the POWER to pull this woman, I have the power to have this man come crawling back for more, I have the power to keep this hidden from my spouse…
It’s basic human nature to try to justify our mistakes. It’s a lot easier to claim she had an affair because of sexual urges and kept going back because the sex was good, rather than admit she had an affair because she reacted wrongly to issues related to her insecurities and/or how she felt about herself.
BC for acne… No. She took BC for BC. Once again: It’s easier to justify BC as acne prevention than as birth-control due to having unprotected sex with her lover. IMHO it would be better for both of you to reach that understanding and accept it. A basic requirement for reconciliation is an acceptance of FACTS.
Finally Bahama: Some posters have mentioned the SAHD aspect. I have always seen a couple as ONE. It’s not her income or her house bought from the proceeds of her income. Its JOINT income gained by the decision on how the MARRIAGE arranges time and tasks. Part of R IMHO is clearing the financial aspects in a marriage. I would use the time ahead to make your position as clear as possible: Who is the beneficiary of her life-insurance, whose names are on the property deeds, whose names are on the bank accounts… It’s not as if you are doing this to scare her into remaining married – it’s simply one very common problem-factor to a marriage that is cleared.