Hi there,
I am so sorry to hear your situation, it is so incredibly painful. It is so hard when you are in the middle of it, it can be difficult to take a step back and look at things objectively. Things that seem so obvious when you are on the outside, mysteriously become so confusing when you are in the throes of it. I would like to share some of my observations based on my own infidelity experience. I am not sure how old you are, so please forgive me if any of this comes across patronizing, that is not my intent.
I googled character and I got back "the mental and moral qualities distinctive to an individual". Character is a critical trait in a partner. Often times, it takes a back seat to looks and charm, but it is decidedly more important. The character of your partner is critical and will come into play frequently as you weather life together. EVERYONE goes through trials and challenges in their lives. Tragedies and illnesses happen to literally everyone, and you need someone who has a solid character and will prioritize you and your in every situation. Your wayward boyfriends actions have disqualified him as a partner. He has demonstrated that he has the capacity for deception and betrayal when everything is normal and the relationship is still new. How can you count on him when you lose your job? Have a miscarriage? Get cancer? Lose your parent? Get in a car accident? All of these things are related, because when it comes down to it, he consistently prioritizes his impulses over your relationship.
Making character changes is hard. The cheater does not like to feel bad. In fact, they use cheating as a coping tool not to feel bad. They generally avoid bad feelings altogether. Examine yourself critically feels really bad, especially if you have been playing a reprising role as a villain in someone else's life. First you have to admit you suck, then you have to do really hard work not to suck (change thought patterns, examine weakness, build boundaries after not ever having any, etc) and the truth is, the thing that gives them permission to cheat is the very same thing that prevents them from any meaningful self-examination. That means your boyfriend would have to do some very intensive therapy work (and maturing) before he would be a good candidate for a long term partner. Does he really have it in him?
Words can be used as a tool for manipulation. They can be very beautiful and give us hope and make us think they really finally "get it". Words are easy, all he has to do is say them and they work! He does not have to take any action whatsoever, he can simply say he will, and that will be good enough! Words alone were enough to keep me in a toxic abusive relationship for SEVEN YEARS. For this reason, I am going to ask you to disregard EVERYTHING that comes out of his mouth and focus solely on his actions. Don't tell him what to do. Why should you fix it, you didn't do anything? Just sit back and observe. If he is truly making meaningful changes, you should see:
-No blame shifting. He takes ALL responsibility for the choices he has made. No blaming other women for pursuing him. No blaming you for not be good enough. He needs to take TOTAL responsibility for the harm he causes.
-Demonstrates he understands the damage he has done. He never criticizes you for taking too long to get over it
-Anticipates your triggers and supports you however you need until you come out of it
-Is not deceptive about other things
-Completely transparent, eager to prove that he is being truthful and faithful
-Checks on you regularly
-Does not use anger to manipulate you into not asking questions or reacting because you are scared he is going to get angry
I am sure others could provide more examples, but you get it. He would make a 180 degree change and it would just FEEL completely different. If you do not see that level of change, then you need to call it. Life is precious, time is precious and you will experience more than just betrayal and cheating, mine also lied about finances, drinking and gambling, but it doesn't even have to be serious betrayal to make you miserable.
My cheater was my second marriage and I also held off on leaving because I didn't want to be that girl who had been married and divorced twice. I also was scared I couldn't hack it on my own as a single mom of two kids. I was also concerned that I would never find healthy love. My fear was a LIAR! I am now a twice divorced, HOMEOWNER, single mom of three kids that is dating the most caring, stand up man. I didn't find my healthy love until I was 40! If I never left my POS XWH, I would still be dealing with his bullshit now, but the fact is that relationship is now just a shitty memory.
Keep posting here, we totally get it. You will get a lot of people that say "LEAVE" and it may feel frustrating cause you just want to fix it, but we are just trying to prevent you from wasting the time, money and energy that we did. Please do not bring your wayward boyfriend here because he can use what we tell you to manipulate you further.
<3