You first posted in JFO at the end of May, not quite 4 months ago. From context, I gather that the post was about a month after your Dday #1. Here are some excerpts from that first post:
I do not want to get into all the gory details.
In the morning I got a text that basically said she was the worst piece of human trash and the apologies started, they kept coming and coming, begging and pleading.
So, we talk and talk and talk. She stays that night, she stays home from work, we talk. She's not letting up.
It's now been two weeks and we've had lots of hysterical bonding. She's still here, she's still sorry and we have talked about so many things and she can see the emotional toll and the extreme hurt and betrayal.
She has not once shifted blame to me or even insinuated that anything was my fault.
she understood that she wasn't happy, but not communicating it
It has all been "my" fault (hers).
I know from reading a LOT of information online that this is a sign of true remorse.
She hadn't really texted or messaged anyone else about this situation so that's all I have to go on. It looks 100% genuine.
To recap, in the wake of your Dday #1, you came here with a post that is almost textbook newly minted BH, reeking of hopium, parsing a few days worth of words to find a simulacrum of "remorse" after 18 months of action loudly stating the opposite (fucking her AP and all of the decisions and sneaking and lying that goes along with that).
It was a natural response. You described your marriage leading up to that point as "20 years together, 2 kids. Always 'perfect'." The first stage of grieving under Kubler Ross is denial. The overwhelming wish of most newly minted BH's is that the infidelity were not true, not real, that the "perfect" marriage that had previously been your emotional reality would remain.
The difficult step is recognizing that your "perfect" marriage is gone, forever. The woman you thought you were married to is not the actual real flesh and blood woman you are in fact married to. That real woman is the kind of person who would betray a man who made a solemn vow with her and worked his ass off for 20 years to fulfill that vow, just because she was feeling vaguely dissatisfied.
I guarantee you that 10 years from now, 20 years, you will stare yourself down in the mirror and see the face of a man whose "perfect" wife spent a year + fucking somebody else. The question, then, is what life do you want to build around that reality.
Unlike many BH's, you never have shared details of the A, or how you discovered it, or the confrontation. If there is one thing I've observed here, it is that details matter. I suspect the reason for this omission is that you know what the overwhelming advice here would be if you provided those details. There are in fact some things that are just too big to overcome. Some insults that cannot heal so long as you remain in the marriage.
On June 17th (almost exactly 3 months ago), you posted:
I am not doing very well actually.
I found some more pertinent details (of the affair, not since) that are even more devastating.
I am getting my ducks in a row and she'll be out soon. I am pretty much done and don't feel like sharing anymore at the moment. I am not sure if I will be back here, just logging on makes it worse for me right now.
Post 1: "It is a sign of true remorse." "It looks 100% genuine".
Post 2: She was lying to my face even when I was believing that she has true remorse and is 100% genuine.
My friend, do you see the cognitive dissonance in your posts? You have difficulty looking at your WW objectively. You are not alone in this. We see it all the time here on SI.
In this current post, you say:
She is exceedingly remorseful, that's clear. I can hear her vomiting in the bathroom after I express my hurt and we cry sometimes. I know her.
Once again, grasping for straws, clinging to ersatz "remorse" without analyzing its authenticity. With all due respect, you don't know her. You know your fantasy of her, your imagination of the fictional woman you put on a pedestal. You are not looking at your flesh-and-blood human wife as the deeply flawed person she really is. I'm saying this because R requires, among other things, a sort of radical honesty, yet, from my perspective, you are persisting with a delusional dishonesty, even to yourself.
We are (except for my episodes) back to our pre wedding days in all ways. Talking, planning, living, emotionally and physically, it's all "perfect". We go everywhere together, we go to bed and sleep together, even if one of us stays up. We greet each other at the door with long hugs and kisses. We are "back".
Gently, that is not what a reconciled marriage looks like. That sort of saccharine charade has a limited shelf life and no nutritive value. It's make-believe as part of an effort to avoid the harsh reality created by the A.
I mean, I am the same guy, I haven't changed, how can she love me this much again all of a sudden after so much time? And how can I, with any self respect, accept her again as my partner in life?
Then there is the "getting away with it" aspect, aside from losing her best friend, no one knows. The in laws sent us a card for our recent anniversary that expressed how proud they were of our perfect marriage how great we were together and what an example we were... you can imagine how I felt about that.
So she basically gets to be the perfect wife in a perfect marriage and I am the only one who's directly affected. It doesn't seem fair. (is that selfish?) I don't want the world to know, but at the same time... I was seriously wronged here.
I guess my question is... I assume these feelings are normal but how long do these feelings last in a relationship that ends up working out? I mean, if we are still together in 3 years am I still going to wake up in a panic, or look at her funny from time to time?
To answer your question, your feelings are 100% normal. My friend, assuming your Dday #2 was in fact the point at which you learned the true extent of the A, you are only 3 months out from Dday. Most posters here observe/experience the emotional roller coaster of discovery for the better part of a year, or more. You're nowhere near a stage of this process where you can even begin to know if you want R or D.
3 years from now will be about the time you find yourself in what is called the "Plane of Lethal Flatness". That is the phase where you realize that, despite all of the HB, all of the masquerading as star-crossed teenage lovers to avoid the hard conversations, all of the hollow apologies and vomiting from her over the fear of losing her financial safety net, every morning when you look at your own mug in the mirror, you will think about that year+ when she was lying to you and sneaking around to fuck another man. EVERY morning. "This is my life, forever." The Plane of Lethal flatness. That forever, stretching out in front of you as far as you can see. "She fucked that guy." What were you doing with the kids at home the first time she came home stinking of her first sex with him? What did she say to you? Did she kiss you? Had she at least brushed her teeth before doing so? I guarantee you that this sort of detail will haunt you.
The question you need to be asking yourself is: what Particle do I want staring me back in the mirror when I have those thoughts? Divorce is not irrevocable. You have kids together. Divorce or not, you will remain in one anothers lives. You can date, have sex, court, re-marry if you choose.
Staying married IS irrevocable. You can never get those years back. SI is filled with BH's who wavered, took no action, and then came back 5, 10, even 40 years later wishing they had divorced.
I'm guessing you married young, which puts you possibly in your mid-40's, with a successful self-build business. A lot of life in front of you.
[This message edited by Butforthegrace at 8:47 AM, September 17th (Thursday)]