Newest Member: WhatnowH


Married 34+ years, together 40+ years
Two awesome adult sons.
Dday 6/16 4-year LTA Survived
Restoration takes time.
"Circumstances don't make the man, they only reveal him to himself." ― Epictetus

There is no R v. D

Borrowing a line from the original Matrix film — there is no spoon — and I ultimately believe there is no real R versus D on SI. Of course there are arguments and discussions for and against, but the perception of those factions may not match reality.

As with the coded program within the Matrix, the protagonist perceives the spoon as real, when it’s simply his perception following the program. When he realizes there is no spoon, he alters his perception of his environment and is literally empowered by that realization.

To put it more simply, whether or not you’ve seen the film, this ongoing discussion about what information our newest members should receive — I think we as a community — do fairly well. I imagine we could probably offer those experiences better at times, but overall, SI has had a lot of success over a lot of years based on all of us sharing how we survived infidelity.

And I think the key is, some members can ONLY relate to their own path and have no idea how someone else’s journey really WORKED for them. I have family members, friends, and friends on SI who have found peace through R and through D. However, I’m only good at sharing how I got through it, because it’s the only one I experienced.

I used to participate in the back and forth and considered there were factions of people Hell bent on trying to get people to choose one path or the other. SOME people who had an WS they could not or would not be able to spend another day with tend to suggest new members follow that path. The same can be said for SOME people who found a way to keep their WS around, they can be as pushy about keeping their mindset in mind.

That’s where I think SI could do better.

In JFO, I think every BS truly cares for the newest members because we can relate to that shock and pain of discovery. I think every BS wants to help them find a way through and again, we tend to relate our OWN experience, since it worked for us.

But we don’t really know our new members and what they need.

And yet, veteran members yell over the top of each other, ignore what they consider the wrong advice and reiterate their own experience, louder and sometimes without regard to what the new member needs.

Some people need to be shocked out of their spiral.

Some people simply need to be heard.

Some people need time to figure things out.

Some people just need kindness.

Instead they get people advocating for the experience they know best, and too often are tone deaf to what the newest and most vulnerable members are asking for. Moderators do what they can, but they are an all volunteer crew with real lives outside of our SI Matrix.

It can take hours or days for a Mod to jump into a thread where a new member is being shocked into silence or worse, the new member leaves before finding the help they were looking for.

I do think most new members find their way here regardless of the advice, be it overly harsh or not harsh enough — depending on one’s perception.

Ultimately, members tend to find people and experiences they relate to and they gravitate in that direction. R and D then tend to get figured out regardless of where people start out after discovery.

I think that’s the magic of SI, that it is an entire collection of perspectives. The wide range of results, the wide range of experiences, each are as real and meaningful as the other.

Those varied experiences truly eliminate the need for some people have to constantly pitch their take as gospel and the only path forward.

There is no R v. D.

SI covers ALL the bases.

If you live in the S/D section, or the NB section, or the R section, you tend to find places to reinforce the choice YOU made or a results you’re hoping for.

It doesn’t make other choices invalid. It just doesn’t.

It’s all about surviving this unique trauma.

Then members pick their path — they all do — regardless of how much people yell at them in JFO to choose one way or the other.

I absolutely got caught in sides or choices early on, but a much wiser member than me suggested that I may not be comfortable with my choice if I needed to constantly DEFEND it. That hit me like a ton of bricks, because it rang true. I was not comfortable (yet) with my choice. Ultimately, I am good now and haven’t a care in the world if someone likes my decision or not. I also understand why people pick a path different than mine, and I’m good with that too.

I tend to not advise people one way or the other anymore, unless they are describing an actively abusive situation or are suicidal, or other emergencies.

I’ve also given some bad advice. Along the way, I suggested one new member should stay and works things out, however, his wife took the A underground and it was a horrific second dday for that member. Another guy asked me directly what to do, and I told him to run, that he had nothing worth saving. He is happily R’d today and was disappointed that I told him to give up on his M.

I personally made it worse for at least two members. Hopefully not much more than that, but our experiences do make a difference.

I don’t imagine everyone will approach new members with caution like I do now, but it is worth considering before blasting a new member with shock and awe OR offering hope where there is none.

Words can help or hinder.

When in doubt, be kind.

There is R, D and limbo, and they all exist, regardless of the limitations of our experience or perception.

You picked a great path. So did I.

And now we try and help those who are still working on THEIR choice instead of selling them one outcome.

5 comments posted: Tuesday, November 16th, 2021

At some point healing becomes a choice

Instead of taking some existing threads off track, I thought it better to start a new thread focusing on the topic of healing.

Regardless of whether people divorce inside of a week, or in 15-years, or if they stayed unhappily married or found a way to reconcile with their spouse, at some point we get to choose to heal.

Don’t get me wrong, I couldn’t possibly ignore the trauma and pain infidelity has brought into my life. I’m just saying somewhere along the way, be it those first two to five years or in year six or year ten, one morning you will have processed the pain to a point where you can choose more misery or more joy as a focus in your existence.

As with every other loss, or other traumatic events we have experienced, we are changed forever.

I always respected the line, "Life is suffering, if anyone tells you different, they’re selling something."

Because I think it is absolutely true.

What is also true is that suffering isn’t the only game in town.

Misery, after so many days, months, years, becomes a choice.

I know, because I lived for a long time, comfortable with my misery. It wasn’t much, but I knew what to expect each day, and there was comfort in consistency. And my theme for life was, life sucks and then we die.

Then I found there are other ways to greet the day. With some appreciation and some gratitude and a focus on the amazing stuff I had accomplished, starting with my two sons.

I had finally figured out ways to find good in each day, while recognizing not every moment is meant to be happy. We have a range of emotions for a reason.

That was before my wife’s confession.

I was more than ready to return to my misery and stay there until the end of time.

Of all the loss in life, and I’ve experienced more than my fair share of family and friends passing on way too young, infidelity may still be the hardest hit I’ve taken.

It really took me the full five years to dust myself off and feel GOOD again.

All the previous mindfulness I had learned evaporated after discovery.

Infidelity is trauma.

It takes time to heal.

We all heal at a different pace too.

But again, at some point, one day, one night, one moment arrives and we KNOW we have a path forward and some choices to make about where we focus our thoughts and our energy.

I just can’t allow my wife’s choices to define me and my existence any longer.

I have power, agency, I have will — I get to choose.

I am changed forever, and SOME of it, is for the better.

I am stronger than I’ve ever been, and I mean emotionally as well as physically. Although my young self may argue with me about the strength level. I’m definitely slower, no chance to break any personal speed records.

That aside, is I get to decide where my thoughts are aimed. Are they aimed in the past, the future, or what I need to get done today?

Like most folks, my mind definitely drifts back from time to time to think about the pain. I also then get to process that thought and focus on something more positive — like the fact I get to see my sons on Thanksgiving, and I can’t wait. And I can add another set of push-ups to the day, just so the kids don’t think their old man is getting soft as he ages.

No mind tricks, no mind games, just focus on the stuff that adds more joy. There is plenty of misery to focus on, but we really don’t have to live there.

SI has been a big part of helping me heal.

It’s been an inspiration to see the members who were here before me hang around to help others heal. There is a ton of good advice here.

Ultimately though, I had to take charge of my healing or face the possibility of being stuck on the misery track where I’ve already spent plenty of time.

I do think we all have the right to be as miserable as we want.

I’m just sharing my experience of breaking out of that mindset.

None of this is to suggest ANYONE HERE has to be on this track.

These thoughts are more for people are SEVERAL YEARS into their recovery.

I know not everyone gets to feeling whole again, I have just found that life is too short to get stuck. And that includes trying to force a way to happiness — that can be a whole other set of problems.

Process it all. Never pretend it didn’t happen.

I think then, we all —eventually — have the strength to choose our focus.

24 comments posted: Thursday, November 4th, 2021

Considering Reconciliation: The odds and the path I chose.

Before deciding whether or not to ‘reconcile’ or rebuild or restore your marriage, some thoughts should be understood and considered before moving forward.

If you’re new to the forum, I’m sorry you’re here, just be sure to understand that none of your spouses choices are your fault.

Nothing we can do can make someone cheat. In order to cheat a person has to make dozens of calculated decisions, including choosing to lie in order to hide those decisions from you. But that’s the damage too. We can’t imagine our status changing overnight from loyal spouse to being completely invisible to the person we trusted most.

It’s trauma we’re being asked to recover from. It’s the emotional equivalent of a high speed vehicle collision. It takes several YEARS to recover from this.

— So now what?
We don’t owe our spouses a second chance. Read the previous sentence again.

If we stay, it should only EVER be because we’re aiming for something worthy of us and our valuable time.

Reconciliation is NOT staying for the kids. It’s NOT staying for financial stability. It’s NOT due to fear of the unknown. Staying for those reasons are leaning into a life of resentment and additional misery on top of the betrayal horror show.

People do stay for all those reasons and more, and I understand why they do. I’m just saying if you’re staying for anything other than a chance for a decent or better life — it’s not reconciliation.

— Don’t Settle!
A good R isn’t settling for less. It’s demanding more. It’s requiring more honestly, more changes, more consideration than at any other point in the relationship.

To me, settling would be allowing the bad behavior to continue, to allow a WS’ un-safe habits to continue, to stay the course.

If you feel like no matter what else you do, you would have to settle for less — then divorce may be your best path forward.

Your standards are intact. You didn’t cheat, you held up your end of the deal.

— What are the odds?
Personally, I love the line, "Never tell me the odds."

That said, the odds are not on the side of reconciliation. I’ve read 31 books on infidelity and relationships, recovery, blah, blah, etc. All of that and 5 bucks gets me a cup of coffee. I’m no expert, but some people need numbers or an idea how rare my experience is to reconcile a marriage.

Our MC was a bit of an expert. He’s been a counselor for 35-years now and at one point he informed us he was a betrayed spouse. His marriage ended in D. He doesn’t set out to ‘save’ marriages, merely to give people enough information to decide for themselves. That said, he agreed with the odds. It’s uphill.

Of all the statistics, or those who need a number, let me put it this way. I think at some point nine out of ten betrayed spouses choose to leave. Sometimes it takes years to get to that choice, but I think that’s the number. Of the people who choose R, if both spouses choose that path together, I’ve read that around 70 percent of those couples succeed.

In other words, if 100 couples go through infidelity, 90 divorce, 10 try R together as a team. Of those 10 couples, 7 make it. So, that’s about 7 couples per 100 dealing with infidelity that find a path to recovery.

Like I said, it’s uphill.

— It takes both people.
You can put all you have into saving the marriage, but you cannot do it alone. I think the biggest reason R fails is one partner or the other is unable to be vulnerable again with the other. In order to feel vulnerable we have to feel safe. Some folks NEVER make it back to safe. That gets back to those odds above.

It’s more than normal to not feel safe for a very long time after infidelity.

Some WS never get back to vulnerable either. They feel like they will never get balance back in the relationship, so they don’t try or they stop trying.

So the WS has to ditch the shame and not hope for ‘normal’ since infidelity obliterates whatever normal used to be.

— What about trust?
Great question and one that gets asked early and often around here.

How did blind trust work for all of us?

It didn’t.

Blind trust isn’t a good idea and best left to fairy tales and amateur gamblers.

The first person you have to learn to trust after infidelity is YOU.

You doubt everything because you can’t believe you missed the signs. Welcome to this club. All of us MISSED every single sign. Because we trusted that if our spouse was unhappy enough to cheat, they would TELL us.

The upside is, when we get hurt bad, we learn fast. We know what the signs look like and feel like, we know what the lies sound like and the methods used to deceive us.

A WS is out to change all of those patterns, all of those things that made them want or need validation from strangers, or it’s not R. If they are holding to the same old stories, same routines, they’re not worth another minute of your time.

Trust yourself first, then allow your WS to earn SOME trust back with consistent, caring actions.

— Will they ever do it again?
None of us know the answer to that. But a WS who does no work, makes no changes, makes little to no effort or only temporarily alters bad behaviors patterns is 100 percent likely to make similar choices in the future.

In my case, my WS not only hated what she did, she hated that the validation and the risk was all for nothing. Being used for a temporary escape from reality wasn’t worth it to her. She still had to work at it to overcome the shame of her choices, that’s something some WS aren’t able to do. IF a WS is unable to ditch the shame, they keep their distance and avoid vulnerability as much as we do after dday.

A WS who owns all their choices, and takes responsibility to help heal the relationship is someone you can at least work with going forward.

— What’s the work?
For me, it was finding my value. I’m awesome, I’ve always been awesome. I’m kind, I hold the door for people, I always stepped in when I saw a bully pushing anyone around. My sons turned out great because I was good father. I served my country for six years as a badass United State Marine. I coached football for 25-years helping guys learn about getting the best out of themselves to help them and their team. All that I don’t need any human to validate me, agree with me or praise anything I’ve accomplished.

But I forgot all of that on discovery day.

It took me time to get back to my badass self.

I didn’t take any shortcuts. Counseling helped some. Music helped some. I worked out, I read about recovery here and in books. I focused on what I liked about me. I let go of the outcome.

The day it doesn’t matter to you whether you’re married or not is the day you can do anything.

That’s when I truly chose to give my wife one last chance.

Her work was similar, she just had farther to go find her value. People know when they make bad choices, and I’m not sure my wife will ever forgive herself, but she did have to let go of the shame. She had to not put up walls and be be defensive. She had to understand why she wanted that validation from someone outside of our relationship.

And she had to help me put this thing back together.

— Yeah, but how the ____ is it better?
Infidelity is as bad or worse than any tragedy in my life so far. I’m in my mid-50’s now, so I don’t challenge the Universe to throw more at me, but I do realize more difficulties are ahead me. That’s life.

I can’t ever control any person in my life or the bad things that happen to me.

I get to control one thing in this world - my response to adversity.

It ain’t a bumper sticker, it’s a choice I get to make. I get to decide how I tackle this and whether I’ll stay in the past or live for today.

I chose to not let whatever my wife did DEFINE me.

I went a step further and decided I would not let her worst choices her worst days define her either.

By doing that, it gave us a shot.

Before infidelity we communicated poorly. We were married young, and we kept all of our horrible habits from our youth, and would talk down to each other and let problems build up on us. We played the stupid games, the power struggles, we competed for attention from the other — it wasn’t all sunshine.

The best part of R for me is building a bullshit free environment.

No games, no leaving issues for later, if I have a problem, I vent it all, on the spot.

It’s liberating compared to how I lived before. That’s better.

My wife and I give to each other instead of take from each other. That’s way better.

We don’t have to fake it or pretend any feelings. If it’s a bad day, if there is a trigger for me, well, WE deal with it together. That’s better too.

I used to say the better M was in spite of infidelity, but the reality is — it’s because of infidelity. Infidelity blew up the marriage, broke the deal, ended the world as we knew it. We made GOOD changes because of the HORROR show she created.

I wouldn’t recommend infidelity to anyone, ever.

I will always hate that it happened. I will never be okay with her choices.

I also am glad we fought our way back.

— A recap for considering R:
1. Don’t Settle. Don’t compromise your standards.
2. Don’t rugsweep - pretending it didn’t happen or stuffing your pain down is like building an emotional time bomb that only gets more powerful the longer ill feelings fester and linger.
3. Confront the initial pain and anger head on — with or without counseling. Just don’t bury it.
4. Decide what YOU want. Ask for what you want.
5. Set the boundaries required for you to move forward and feel safe.
6. Let go of the outcome. The only person you can control in this life is you.
7. Blind trust is never a good idea. In all seriousness, 100 percent trust in any human is not a good idea. How did that innocent take on trust work out for any of us?
8. If you’re going to rebuild the relationship, you have to find a way back to vulnerable.
9. Accept the facts of what happened, however you can always be NOT okay with those facts.

27 comments posted: Wednesday, September 15th, 2021

Five Years Later

Well, actually a week or two ahead of the official day my wife revealed the secret she was originally going to take to the grave.

I'm a few days early, because I'll be much farther off the grid than normal. We will be on vacation and then we will be moving to a different state and living out of suitcases for a month or two looking for a new place to live.

The update is, we're good.

We're really, really good.

The first two years here I couldn't imagine being where we are now. The first 24-months were shock and awe, sleep deprivation and a substantial depression. We had that moment when we were not sure that love and kindness was going to be enough to revive --- us.

For newer members here, I'm not advocating for any particular choice or direction. Only you can figure out what you want and need.

That's kind of how our recovery, reconstruction, renewal and/or restoration finally started. As year three kicked off, I decided what I really wanted from life, what I would need for our marriage to continue and if we would both be able to get back to being all in (the state of vulnerability and enough trust and let love back in).

It wasn't a one day thing, it was a relentless build back with two or three thousand setbacks.

Eventually, I trusted the work she was doing. Eventually she trusted I could still see the good in her, despite those previous poor choices.

I know why SI has new members focus on themselves. Because you can't know what you want or need until you believe in YOU first. The first thing after infidelity that happens is we lose our faith in our judgment. We lose our swagger. We lose life as we understood it.

We got lucky with a great IC/MC, that helped. I got lucky with AMAZING people here at this site who reached out to me with their concerns and care.

I'd really like to offer up the idea that the flashbacks and thoughts vanish completely. They don't. I wish I could say a lot of things to make newer members feel better.

To borrow from Churchill, "The only way through Hell is to keep going."

So I did.

I made it the other side.

Our marriage is finally what we always wanted it to be. The word authentic gets tossed around too much, but when we live without games, manipulations, masks, it is quite liberating.

I stayed because I wanted to give her a chance.

I would like to think I wouldn't have stayed for kids or money, but in our case, the kids were grown and we've earned a solid living where money doesn't keep us up at night like it did in our younger years.

Anyway, short story long -- I'm extremely happy with my choice.

As I've said a few times, I will always hate what happened, I will never be happy to have suffered through infidelity. However, I am glad we hung in there despite what happened.

I spent way too much time going over what I could have done different. It wasn't me. It's not on me. I am not the sum of my wife's bad choices.

I spent way too much time wondering how my life could have been different. That turned out to be a huge waste of energy.

No one gets out of this thing without suffering or damage. It's part of the deal. Some people deal with other loses, or gambling or drugs, or alcohol issues. One of my tragedies is infidelity. I would NOT have voted for that one. I'm not sure I would pick any other tragedies out either.

We don't get to pick which traumas we get.

We do to choose how to respond.


Even the most mindful people are initially crushed by infidelity.

But somewhere along the way, I got to choose my response. I got to choose what I wanted.

My wife relentlessly loved me back to level. That was not easy. I was not easy.

Now, we are glad we didn't give up.

New life, new adventure awaits. There will always be embers in the air from the fire that burned the marriage to the ground, but they tend to drift away now, much faster than they used to.

30 comments posted: Monday, May 17th, 2021

Updates and the work of R

I tend to take a few months off at a time now, but I still get messages from folks here. I got two recent contacts from members with one wondering if things had gone off the rails for me and contributed to my time off-line.

I'd say even in pandemic world, life is going as well as possible. Although, I'm as burned out on zoom calls as everyone else is.

I also got asked about how I got back to happy in my marriage.

That is the billion dollar question for all of us after infidelity and somehow finding a way forward with the person who obliterated the relationship.

To review, it ain't easy.

We're at about five years out from discovery. It took me two full years to get out from under the pain, anger and trying to figure out if love and kindness would be enough for us to survive my wife's horrible choices.

I decided not to settle. I decided to ask for the relationship we should have built the first time through. I decided if she was willing to change and be vulnerable, I could change and be vulnerable.

I simply wanted to be able to tell myself and my sons that I did all I could to make the marriage work.

The thing about R is, there is no one recipe to rebuild the marriage. Take the path you need, you've earned all the choices you make in R.

I understand so many members focus on what happened in the past versus what can happen today. It makes sense. No relationship in the history of humanity is infidelity proof. The moment we think it can't happen seems to be when the trouble starts.

The truth is every relationship we have or used to have or will have is based on the strength of connection.

How many people are in our rear view mirror because the connection broke or did a slow fade? Out of the dozens of great Marine Corps pals I had, I'm only in contact with two of them these days. It's because we moved on from those crazy military days.

My wife made her horrible choices -- in part -- because she rationalized a loss of connection with me. The bigger problem for her was the external validation she got. All of that is on her, not us.

The re-connect after infidelity is brutal.

First you have to learn to trust yourself again. Then you have to recognize your value, to know you will be fine however the marriage turns out. Your WS has to ditch the shame and be all in -- which isn't always easy. Whenever people hurt people, on purpose, they feel bad and can't imagine themselves ever being close to us again. Some WS never get beyond the shame.

That work of R boils down to both people working back toward each other.

The only way I can ever suggest someone stays to R is if the relationship can be better and stronger than it was.

I couldn't do the "old life" versus the "new life" take.

My life is the whole big picture. It includes my work, my sons, my brothers, my friends and my wife. Like everyone else, it includes trauma.

I survived loss before. I survived infidelity too.

Infidelity is a part of my existence, a part that neither my wife or I ever imagined would be something we would have to deal with.

Overcoming great adversity and loving each other despite that trauma is a rare and beautiful thing.

Why beautiful?

When two people accept each other faults and all, when they finally understand that it's not a sacrifice to give to the other and be honest about everything, that's when a real connection forms.

We've never been closer.

Oh yeah, the innocence is lost. We mourned that. We moved forward.

It's not that we pretend the horror show didn't happen. We just understand the damage it caused and work hard to show each other kindness and care. There isn't any way to make up that lost time, but it can be fun trying to make up for it anyway.

In early recovery I often lamented about, is this how life is meant to be? And why me?

Every life takes bad turns. I don't know a single soul in my life who hasn't been inflicted with some kind of pain, be it a partner who had substance abuse issues, or financial infidelity or alcoholism or domestic abuse, or medical issues (cancer, etc) or the dreaded infidelity.

Pain happens.

My choice for moving beyond this pain was giving my wife one more shot.

I honestly thought I was one person who couldn't ever get to a place of peace again with the person who hurt me. But I'm really, really glad I did.

13 comments posted: Monday, March 8th, 2021

Cookies on®® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20220428 2002-2022® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy