Our situation is so unique that I don't even know if it was an affair.
If you've read books and watched movies about infidelity, I'm not sure what you think is so unique?
Your husband is a cheater. Cheaters lie.
Your husband is admitting to you that he had a physical affair with another woman. Kissing, holding hands, touching her butt? That's all physical. Sexting? That part falls somewhere between and EA (emotional affair) and PA (physical affair).
The OW (other woman)/AP (affair partner) is telling you he's a liar, that it went further and they slept together. What does she have to gain from telling you this?
The OBS (other betrayed spouse) is telling you they had a paternity test done to confirm her pregnancy/child is her husbands. The only reason why they would need a paternity test is if the OW was sleeping with other people. Why would the OBS lie to you about this? What does he have to gain?
My husband has taken 2 polygraphs and failed.
Why do you think he failed two polygraphs? (This isn't a retorical question, I'm curious.)
But, even over 3 years later, he is still holding onto his plea of they never slept together.
Well... he's a cheater, and cheaters lie. There are a few posters on here (one very recently) that were lied to by their WS (wayward spouses) for YEARS about things like whether on not that had full-blown PIV (penis is vagina) sex, and then two, five, ten years later the truth comes out.
He says he was with her because she was skinnier and prettier and even had me do dangerous surgeries so he would not cheat again but he still did.
This is incredibly cruel. Had you do dangerous surgeries? Why not just say, "fuck this shit," and leave? Who was paying for these surgeries? Why didn't you express to the doctor/surgeon your reservations? And if you're saying "so he would not cheat again but he still did," why are you not sure if he had an affair?
He told me that he was in love with his affair partner but he has never felt the way he did with her and he has never been able to show me love. He has admitted, recently, that he has always been searching for someone else.
Again, this is incredibly cruel and you deserve better. If he has always been searching for someone else, let him. Work on healing yourself and then maybe find someone that has always been searching for you.
Was it an affair?
Yes. What makes you think it wasn't?
Why have I stayed?
This is something you need to figure out. We can't tell you why. If you're not in counseling, I would recommend you find someone that specializes in trauma, abusive relationships and/or antisocial personality disorder.
Am I just a piece of shit?
Absolutely not!! I think that you might be in an abusive situation though, and need help. Do you have any family or friends that you can confide in for support?
I feel like I deserve better sometimes but he tells me I have to WAIT for him to get better.
You deserve better all the time, and no, you don't have to wait around and put up with his abuse and wait for it to happen. Not to mention, I don't think people with antisocial personality disorder and/or psychopathy are capable of having true empathy or remorse for their actions. Is it even possible for him to get better? What actions is he taking? Can you meet with his psychiatrist and/or counselor?
The other part wants to stay for our son. I know he has never loved me and never will. He gets so huffy and rolls his eyes every time I say this. He has been diagnosed with Antisocial personality disorder on the Psychopathy side and is definitely a Passive aggressive Narcissistic person (not diagnosed).
Why would you want to raise your son around him? I understand he's his father so you can't keep him away from him entirely, but please research what happens to children raised by narcissistic parents.
My question is..why did I never make him feel that way? I was a model when I met him and extremely beautiful. He was this young kid who was a gamer nerd with little friends. I constantly built him up and his friends were envious and told him how he was "living the dream". I cooked and cleaned, we had amazing sex..often! Every day! I dressed up everyday for him and tried everything to make him feel my equal.
It has nothing to do with you, and everything to do with him. Google "they always affair down."
Now his behavior just keeps getting worse and his excuses are "I just feel I can't do anything right."
He had sex with an ex during the first week of us talking to get to know each other. He was even trying to hook up with another girl prior to his affair. After his affair, he continued to look for someone else and that has not stopped.
This behavior is NOT OKAY. You deserve better than this!!!!! So, so much better. Please find yourself a therapist and start figuring out why you're remaining in this abusive situation. Please start meeting with lawyers to get advice and figure out your options.
But why was he able to give it so freely to her but has never been able to do that for me?
We have been together for 6 years. He even admits he has never been in love with me and still wants me to lose weight now.
ForeverGrey, there is something wrong with him. That's why he's a shitty, cheating, verbally abusive partner. Why do you want to be with someone that doesn't love you? Not with his words, and certainly not with his actions. Why do you want this relationship to be the model your child sees? Would you want someone to treat your child like this? Or would you want your child to treat another person the way you're being treated? Your child is going to grow up thinking one of the two is normal.
Yes, I think you need to lose some weight immediately -- about 180 lbs. or it (or however much he weighs).