Thanks HouseofPLane!
Iceman, I don’t mean what I say as a threadjack, because it may be controversial, but I think this might be helpful for you to hear in your deliberations on how you’re going to proceed.
A big question posed to me by my therapist – sitting in a chair days after finding out my “soulmate” had carried on long term affairs for the majority of our marriage – was this:
Therapist: What do you want to happen?
Me: I’d like to save my marriage.
Therapist: Why?
Me: Because I love her.
Therapist: What does love mean to you?
I’ve pondered this question for years.
I’m a cynic by nature, due to what I do for a living. I’ve watched people engage in almost every form of lying to justify actions that society would view as reprehensible.
I don’t think anyone is a bad person, at least not entirely. I do believe that that anyone is capable of incredibly terrible actions. The common thread in those situations – doing something awful - is that we tend to offload moral responsibility for those actions with post hoc justification.
“I may have robbed that liquor store and shot the clerk, but I am a good person and take care of my grandmother. Who will take care of her if I got to jail?”
“I may have stolen my business associate’s money and lost it all on a cocaine fueled bender in Vegas, but I’m an addict and I have it under control now. I’m really a good person when I am not around my triggers.”
“I may have had affairs, but I was in a sexless marriage and my wife was mean to me all the time. I wanted to stay together for the kids, but I just couldn’t live like that anymore and something had to change.”
It’s kind of the same way we switch our moral compass to fit the narrative of the main character in a movie or a book. We want to identify with the main character because we subconsciously read our own narrative into the story as the main character.
The issue with affairs boils down – eventually – to one of honesty and integrity. Were there issues in the relationship? Sure. There always are. Could you get into apportioning blame for those issues? Yup. No matter if you caused 99% of the problems in a relationship, you are still deserved of having a frank and honest talk before someone takes your health, safety and security without your knowledge to pursue the missing parts of their lives.
Honesty is the essence of the marriage. Do we lie to each other? Absolutely. “Honey this stew is delicious… but maybe next time we shouldn’t use ham in it.” Do we shade the truth to avoid hurting other’s feelings? Yes. All the time. It’s human.
Do people that kill other people walk into a police station and give a full confession and accept punishment without complaint? Not normally. We all want to avoid the negative effects of our actions.
So, in a way, what your WW is doing is incredibly human and also incredibly dishonest. It doesn’t make her the worst person ever created. But it does leave you with certain knowledge.
You now know:
1.) She can lie to your face.
2.) She can offload guilt to the point you don’t notice her having any of it.
3.) She can take advantage of you for what you bring her.
This leads to the conclusions that, in the future:
1.) You don’t really know what she is thinking.
2.) You won’t be able to detect if she is telling you the truth.
3.) She has no qualms about doing something horrible for an extended period of time so long as it suits her needs.
The issue then becomes, is a relationship sustainable? I’d argue that she cannot change those aspects of herself – they’re inherent.
She’s been in therapy for years, likely complaining about your relationship issues, all while NEVER revealing she has been having an affair for years. Therapists have to keep secrets. She didn’t even trust the therapist with that. That should tell you something here.
So, that brings us back to the question… what is love?
I’ll be the first to admit, even now, that I have no idea what it is. I think it’s a word, and one that I now refuse to use.
I could say “I love apples” but what am I really saying with that? I’m saying, “I like the taste of apples and the sensation of chewing them. They make me feel full.”
I could say, “I love you [person]” and what would I really mean by that? Is it the chemical rush I get when I see them? Is it the feeling of safety I get being with them? Is it sexual or platonic attraction? I think the word is something you define for yourself or with the other person.
You’ll be all over the place – sitting in shock, trying to work through issues with a mind that barely functions, trying to make sense of a life that doesn’t make sense anymore. And, if you’re like me, then you’ll use the word “love” to justify what you’re doing.
But, there’s danger there. You’ve had a hole blown in the hull of your emotional ship, and it’s taking on water. You’ll chase her sometimes. You’ll want your “family” back.
The hard truth is her feelings for you have not, for three years at least, been the same as your love for her.
If she was honest, what I think she would say is that she feels she settled for you, she’s supporting you and the family, and she thinks she is entitled to more, so she took it. If she uses the line that “I never meant to hurt you” remember that she was having unprotected sex… she didn’t mean to hurt you, but she also didn’t care enough about you NOT to hurt you in a possibly life altering way. It’s that indifference mindset that comes into play here – the opposite of love.
If you accept the fact that she does not care about you then you have to wonder what she does care about? Her image, her fun, her money, her power, her career…? That’s what she will protect.
Her moving money is a move to protect what she cares about – money.
Her text and subsequent return message of “you’re a good mother” tells you something. She’s told the other man and woman all about her kids (and the gifts). That IMAGE is what she cares about. She’s not really a great mom, spending her kid’s possible college fund on a kink fantasy.
Moving money without telling you, having affair(s)… that’s about power – you’re not part of her partnership.
Her statement that she is OK with divorce or reconciliation is an outcropping of her lack of caring how this plays… she’s got what she actually cares about and she doesn’t need you for it.
The “new” desire more for reconciliation… that’s just about narrative in my opinion. She doesn’t really care. She’s ready for it to be over. She just wants to have something to say down the line, and if she can string you along for a bit longer the divorce can be about “happiness” or you “not being able to accept her apology” and not about “spending the kid’s college fund on male hookers.” That’s embarrassing and doesn’t fit into her image.
And that’s fine. Relationships run their course. You can forgive her later if you want, but I doubt she cares if you forgive her at all.
And that’s why you need a lawyer. It’s not you taking the money for you… but God knows you at least deserve a fair split after this. It’s about making sure the kids are supported. She might find more expensive hookers, you know. (Just injecting some levity…hopefully.)
So, that’s my grand thing to think about. Look to actions, not to words. Look for the real motivations, not stated motivations, and act accordingly.
Also, keep your mouth shut about your feelings around her… she doesn’t care about your feelings or will use them against you. Don’t expose her yet. Wait to talk to an attorney and do EXACTLY what the attorney says. You might need to be able to use the information you have to strategic advantage.
Be safe out there.