Dear Iceman,
I would think you were crazy and your reaction to this unnatural if I had not gone through something similar myself and had similar reactions. You’ll likely deal with the shock of this for a long, long time. Think years. I am sorry.
I think you have received some excellent advice regarding the divorce aspect of your problems. For a long time, you have been a hands-off the finances stay-at-home husband and it is only now that you are playing catch up.
At a minimum, what’s fairly obvious is that your WW does not have respect for you. She’s, in essence, using you for child care and a vision of respectability for her public persona. I know this hurts to hear, but it is one of those “objective truths” that we have a hard time wrapping our heads around. We will wildly swing from idea to idea to justify how they could have loved us all those years, when, indeed, our wayward spouses did something so incredibly unloving that it’s impossible to think they did.
When you discover something like a multi year affair, I think it’s fair to believe that the person having the affair – while it was ongoing – did not love you. I think it’s also fair to say that for some time before the affair, that they also did not love you either (they need to justify the action that their mind has already decided is the course they are going to take).
The justifications – that you didn’t do X,Y or Z and therefore I “had” to have an affair – is BS that they have fed themselves to justify what they are doing.
Do people have sex outside of marriage? Sure. Do some people do it ethically? Yup. To have an ethical outside relationship you give your spouse a choice. You say “I am not feeling attracted to you and I don’t feel attached to you. I haven’t been attracted to you for some time. I want to be with someone I am attracted to, but I don’t want to lose the stability of our family. I want to sleep with other people to the point where I will end the marriage to do so. If you wish to have an open marriage then I would prefer it. You may find other suitors as well. If you want an open marriage, let’s discuss ground rules. If you want to divorce, then we will spilt and be great coparents to our children.”
That’s an ethical – but cruddy – conversation to have.
It tells you what they are going to do and it gives you a choice what you want to do. It hurts, but at least it’s upfront. It shows respect and gives you a choice.
What affairs are – at their core – is a plethora of dishonesty. The other party is willing to risk your health to have sex with other people. The other party is seeking an imbalance in the relationship where they get their needs met, and you do not get yours met. In effect, they are emotional thieves and time stealers. It’s not intentionally meant to hurt you – that’s valid. It is intentionally a choice to get everything that they want at your expense (there’s a slight different there). And if you don’t know, then it won’t hurt you. Win-win in their minds.
But, they’d be SUPER pissed if, because of the complete lack of affection in your relationship, you sought out kinky threeways and spent all the marital funds on hookers.
The reason I am writing here – assuming this is a real post – is to warn you regarding the mindset you’re likely going to slip into here.
You’ll post hoc try to find a way to believe she loved you during this time – that the evil massage therapist took advantage of your poor WW. You want to be mad at him so you can justify that she loved you, but some combination of a charming charlatan tempted your weak and confused partner.
Get that idea out of your head.
Right now your WW appears to be preparing for a divorce. She’s had three years to prepare – once she took that step of getting a lover you likely became the enemy that she’s preparing to leave.
The money stuff is SUPER fishy. Common advice is given to people on how to get prepared for divorce. Syphoning off money is one of those ways. She could have been doing this for years – extract cash from the marital account and deposit it into another (possibly in the name of an LLC or other vehicle like a trust), or stockpiling it in a safe deposit box or with a friend. She could have been taking cash payments too that never hit your marital account or been skimming with an auto debit from her salary. She could have been using it to purchase crypto currency that you have almost no way to trace.
Long story short – the advice to get a forensic accountant is necessary. Further, you will probably want, as part of the divorce case, to have the accountant examine the company books as well.
The way to deal with this – even with the shock and emotions – is to file and walk.
In her mind, what she really, truly wants, is a divorce. She just can’t say it. Because then she is the “bad guy.” She will pay lip service to reconciling, but she will not release her entitlement problem. She doesn’t want to be thought of badly. I think – ideally – the narrative she wants is “we grew apart, I had an affair, we both tried to fix it but there was just too much damage on both sides to get past. We are great coparents now and the kids have adjusted well.”
That’s what she wants to tell her friends and any potential suitors in the future.
In terms of the reality that she wants – she wants to get as much money as possible, pay as little as possible in alimony and child support, and have you to care for the kids while she lives the high life. But, she also wants that narrative I mentioned above.
In my case, my EXWW made her affair so blatantly obvious at the end that my subconscious powers of denial couldn’t stop me from finding out. I too tried to reconcile. But, realistically, that wasn’t what my EXWW wanted.
I say this because maybe you’re dealing with something different. I divorced in many ways for her. It’s got to be exhausting to have someone in love with you that you cannot stand – but that you have to pretend to love. The act is so much work, I think. Mine wanted out, but couldn’t say it.
Again, we all read in our own stories here, so take what applies and leave the rest.
What does appear objectively obvious is that you’re dealing with a spouse that has the ability to lie like a sociopath and the self preservation to prepare for the fallout. You’re probably behind the eight ball here, and you need an attorney to advise you competently.
I normally only chime in when someone is in danger – and that’s you. The likely outcome is either divorce now, or divorce after a few years of “trying” so that it doesn’t look like the reason for the divorce is her affair – but rather the squishy reasoning of “we are not happy.”
Letting the marriage go on for longer allows her to become better prepared for the divorce – such as reducing her income to avoid alimony and child support. Or becoming a more involved mother in case she’s going for custody. Personally – I’d discuss with an attorney prior – but I think that you are probably better off striking while the iron is hot.
Also, as mentioned previously, keep a VAR on you and keep it recording ALL THE TIME. Upload to files to a separate drop box account or something she doesn’t have access to. Keep it on even when she’s not there because you never know when you need an alibi in court. If she gets cornered she could make a domestic violence claim for her advantage. (It doesn’t always happen, but it happens enough to make this common advice.)
Also, don’t sleep with her at all. First, no one wants an STD. Second, it can impact “at fault” proceedings.
Again, sorry you’re here. Do with this information what you will. Play this safe because, again, you are in a fair bit of danger here.