3) I had no idea about the other guy from 7 years ago. None. I don't remember her acting weird, coming home later, being unreachable on her phone, being secretive. I have to admit, at that point in our lives we drifted apart a little bit.
You're taking at least partial responsibility for maybe your wife's behavior, but also not realizing her behavior was secretive and weird.
The real problem is that your wife can live a secret life of betrayal and not even bat an eyelash.
Also she can live a secret life of betrayal and tell herself it is no problem and not even care about how she has behaved toward you. It doesn't bother her at all.
PLEASE NOTICE: The only thing that has truly caused her any personal angst is that she was caught and that she was "in trouble".
We were both working long hours, we just started our careers so it was given. But we talked about it a we pushed through because we knew this was only temporary. She said last night she dealt with it in the worst possible way and asked for forgivness.
This is what normal long-time couples building a life and family go through.
Sure there is pressure. Pressure reveals character.
That part I bolded in the last quote? There is gonna be a lot of that from your wife.
4) She's working with her IC on a way of adressing this in not a self-destructing way. She has troubles with self-worth and seeks validation from outside. Her IC called her "immature for her age" when it comes to interpersonal relationship and when dealing with a stressful situations. There is a ton of work to do on this
I still don't like this shared therapist model. Please, even if you keep the shared therapist, get one for yourself.
You must see by now that your wife has been lying your therapist the whole time as well, and that information gets fed to you via the therapist.
"This was the only time, we only went this far, I am so sorry and remorseful, I'll do anything!!" etc. and then that information gets sent along to you.
Did the therapist ever say to you or her "she's obviously lying her ass off"?
***
Having said that, your therapist was absolutely right, that she is immature. But that is a soft, "kid-gloves" assessment.
Unfortunately, and this is why therapy for cheaters is mostly bullshit, your wife is also untrustworthy, selfish, callous, and dishonorable. She is just not a loyal person.
This accountability cannot be externally implanted by a therapist, it's really a character issue.
***
Mr Flibble, Whatever your wife did or did not "do" with whatever men she has been playing around with on the side during your relationship, you have to ask yourself: Can you live with a person who has such poor character?
Granted, you're both relatively young, but you are also both full-fledged adults.
I am not a big proponent of people changing their character. It happens, but it is not very common.
Time to think about what kind of person you want to share your life with going forward, in addition to specific events and acts.
[This message edited by faithfulman at 9:45 AM, April 21st (Wednesday)]