You have the affair itself and then you have each hurt, each betrayal within that affair. Each one needs to be processed separately.
WOES- this nails it for me.
bc the WS personally chose & experienced each of those individual betrayals, it seems s/he comes to the dday table with all of that intact. Rather than get graphic / gross with a shit sandwich analogy, let's say the A is something else, like a duck.
The WS knows it's a duck, bc the WS has personally seen it, heard it, petted it, played with it, and interacted with the duck in many (unfortunate) ways. They know it's a duck. Once or twice we BS may have thought we caught wind of a some kind of bird in the house (what was that noise, honey?). But the WS tells us it's nothing, it's the wind, it's a cat, or whatever - they simply lie about our perception of anything scary or concerning being in the picture.... being in our sphere of (a relatively safe) life.
Then on dday, suddenly appears a duck on our pretty dining room table in the midst of dinner, squawking and clucking and pooping all over EVERYTHING. We cannot process that it is even here, or that it's even a duck. We were deaf and blind to the existence of ducks in our world. We've never seen a duck, or not one that looked like THIS. We can't understand that it exists and we REALLY can't understand how it got into our homes or onto our table. So we ask questions to try and reconcile our perceptions to the new reality of this duck walking over our lovingly prepared dinner. We ask if it has feathers, and a beak, and what kind of nails are on its feet. We ask what that quacking noise means, cuz we've never heard such a sound. We ask (over & over & over) how and why our loved ones could let a duck come to the table and poop all over our healthy food. The WS gets flabbergasted, and keeps saying "it's just a duck with some poop, we'll just shoo it away and get back to our regularly scheduled dinner" and they simply cannot understand how we don't see it as a duck, let alone that it is a dangerous, family murdering, duck (like the rabbit in Monty Python's Holy Grail).
When I experienced dday, I just could not understand any of it. I'd ask my WH questions and he'd get very angry and frustrated. He would roll his eyes and say things like "that's what you do in an affair" or "that's what an affair is" as if I was a complete idiot (note to newbies: probably not a good idea to follow my WH's examples here). Even trying to understand the lies he told would be met with "secrets are part of having an A", as if I was just too dumb to see this.... as if there was something wrong with ME for not having a brain (or lack of morality) that would immediately see and recognize and understand I was dealing with a duck. The list of things I don't understand is still quite long. By his continued refusal to come completely clean, by still refusing to put in the time and effort to provide a true and detailed timeline, he continues to deny me the opportunity to heal the 1000s of cuts he (or his fucking duck) made into my heart and soul.
I've never been stoned to death, but being a BS feels like what I imagine stoning to be: you are laying on the ground, suffocating and unable to breathe from the weight of it all. My WH perceived what was on my chest as a single 200lb boulder that he called "having an A". But to me, it's a bag full of thousands of rocks, from pebbles to boulders, that holds 200 lbs. That bag has no distinct name, as it consists of rocks of various sizes named "having sex" and "kissing" and "lying" and "flirting" and "gaslighting" and "abandonment" and "I'm not worthy" and "where did you go" and "I must be an awful wife" and "what did you discuss" and "breaking my confidences with a stranger" and "what makes her so special you threw me in the trash can" and "unloveable" and "where was I on x day" and "hotel rooms" and "deleted texts" and the thousands upon thousands of hurts caused by his lying and cheating over the course of our relationship.
He thinks by removing the big rock (the one he calls "the affair" ), I will be able to breathe. And to some degree, he is correct. Removing the biggest rock may allow me to breathe sufficiently to not die (at least not quickly). What he does not understand is that I need to see and inspect and process each and every one of those pebbles, each and every rock, and each and every boulder that still resides on my chest. What he does not understand is that I may be breathing by his removal of the biggest boulder, but it is not sufficient to provide a healthy, life sustaining, amount of oxygen. What he doesn't understand is that even after the biggest boulder is removed, I am still pinned to the ground by the weight of all the remaining rocks of varying sizes.
And ETA: at the same time I am trying to identify/process each pebble/rock in the "having an A" bag, I am simultaneously dealing with ANOTHER set of weights constantly being added to my chest (& impairing breathing) called, "trickle truth" and "defensiveness" and "minimization" and "not doing the work" and "breaking NC" and "continued lies" and "unworthy" and "I'm ashamed I've not divorced" and "PTSD" and all the other weight that is put upon a BS after dday while a WS does not get or own "it".
[This message edited by gmc94 at 4:21 PM, March 20th, 2020 (Friday)]