36,
If you went through this thread, copied out just your posts, and made a single document out of them, what impression do you think a counselor or psychiatrist would get of your wife? What comes across in one scenario after another is that for your wife, it seems to be a series of control and power games, with her constantly trying to force you into a subordinate position. And if you try to change that power dynamic, how does she react?
When you decided to spend a night at a hotel, you had to be taught a lesson. Cue false DV calls to the police, which your wife made in co-operation with the OM.
You go dark and stop responding to her every need, she blows your phone up. How dare you slip the leash, you're not getting away that easily.
In the middle of the affair, she brought the OM into your home, to lie to your face about the affair, then to suggest you chauffeur them around town for their pleasure, like some kind of servant, with the aim of finishing the evening with a threesome in which you would watch him have sex with your wife, most likely in the bedroom you share with her. It would have been the ultimate humiliation, and your wife was fine with that, because all of her actions seem to be about enforcing a hierarchy of power within the relationship, rather than about love between equals.
From what you say, you have bent over backwards to show your love and devotion, and acts of love are one of the 'love languages'. Some people might appreciate that, but it seems like your wife came to take you and your devotion for granted, and possibly progressed beyond that to seeing it as dependence, which put her in a position of power over you in the relationship. You became the worshiper, she became the worshiped. And she got used to that. And maybe, after a while, your acts of love started to lose their meaning to her, because she had to do so little to keep receiving them.
And then the OM showed up. An experienced and cynical player who knew just how to manipulate women at an age where they are starting to lose their looks and confidence. Using a combination of teasing and temptation to make ideal candidates identify themselves to him, he would then make these women convince him why he should give them all the good things he had to offer. He made them work for it, with the reward of the ego kibbles and reassurance about their looks that they made the grade and were good enough for him. And one woman after another fell for it.
Working in that office must have been like shooting fish in a barrel for him. He played it so well that the women ended up in competition with each other for him. He must have a huge disdain and disrespect for every woman who falls for his technique, but they are so desperate for his validation that they see giving themselves to him as a privilege. Or he drugs, beats, and rapes them. Whichever technique gets him what he wants.
And your wife's ludicrous quote about the OM being a 'better' man than you? It is all about power. You will bring your tribute to her feet if she does nothing at all to deserve it. The OM, on the other hand, made her work for his attention, and keep working for it. And she was impressed by that, and took it as a sign of manliness. She became subordinate to him, and made her marriage and family subordinate to him.
However, as she herself acknowledged when you suggested the OM should pay her hairdresser's bill, there is no way on earth he would do that. That is not how the power dynamic between her and the OM works, and she is fine with that. When she needs a bill paid, a shelf put up, a car crash administrated, she comes to you and lets you do the work, because that is how the power dynamic works between you.
What she established with the affair was an utterly unhealthy power hierarchy in which the OM was King, she was Queen, and you were her faithful servant. I am sorry to put it that way, because you are a great guy, worthy of much better treatment and love, but every interaction involving you and your wife, or you, your wife, and the OM, seems to indicate that is how your wife saw things.
You say that your wife will not take responsibility for her actions, and that she tells you that you just have to 'get over it'. That sounds very much like she does not see it as her position within the power hierarchy in the relationship to have to explain or justify anything to you, because a Queen does not justify herself to a servant. And whenever you want to be treated as an equal, or - God forbid! - as someone she should answer to, she responds with outraged anger, and acts of punishment like the false DV charges, to try and put you back in the place she has assigned you in the relationship. Which is serving her, and letting her do whatever she wants.
It is possible that there were always elements of that power dynamic within the relationship, but you were happy to let it slide because you were happy loving her and showering her with praise and affection, using your support as a means of demonstrating your love. So the unhealthy aspect of the unequal balance within the marriage did not show itself or cause problems for years. And then the OM appeared, and the full extent of your wife's view of you as a subordinate blew up into its full ugly blossom, understandably causing a substantial shock to you.
It is hard to gauge whether or not your wife is still involved with the OM. She is certainly unlikely to be honest about it, but even if he is out of the picture, her dismissive attitude to you, telling you to 'get over it', and doing none of the things a remorseful wayward would do, coupled with her rage if you do anything to escape her control, indicate that her affair mind-set about where you stand in the relationship hierarchy is still very much in operation. For you, it may be about love, but for her, it seems to be about power, and that is why I think you have hit such a brick wall as far as her conciliatory actions have gone.
I believe that your wife's lies and crude manipulation in the MC session are an attempt to turn them into a process that makes you the bad guy, makes you feel responsible for the affair, and which absolves her of any responsibility. If she could manage it properly, you would be on your knees, apologising to her, with the counselors applauding you for taking ownership of your poor behaviour.
Only...You're not allowing that to happen to you, are you? She lies, and you call her out on it straight away. That is very healthy. It is starting to destroy the unhealthy power dynamic in the marriage, and to release your from your subordinate position. However, as healthy as that may be, it feels odd and jarring to you to be doing that.
The same is true of your going 'dark' on the communications front, because you keep trying to live up to an ideal you have of what a supportive husband should do. So when you start taking steps and making progress to break out of the box that your wife has put you in, you end up feeling like you are at war with yourself, and failing to be a 'good' husband.
The combination of your wife's attitude that you should be subordinate to her in the marriage, and your own idealised image of what you have to do to be a 'good' husband have effectively trapped you between a rock and a hard place, haven't they? And I think it is your pressure on yourself to live up to your idealised 'husband' role that is the element that needs to change so you can break out of that trap.
How about, instead of putting pressure on yourself to be so supportive to someone who has not been very supportive of you, you re-focus your energy and create a new ideal role model for yourself, as an independent human being who does not need to keep validating himself by serving his wife, and who will not accept anything other than being an equal within the marriage, rather than a subordinate?
Honestly, you are not being a bad guy or a failure as a 'good' husband when you fight against your subordinate role, because you should never have been put into that role in the first place. Unfortunately, that was how your wife interpreted your supportive actions, and why she thought it was fine to have an affair.
She felt so totally secure about your devotion that she even admitted to you that she laid beside the OM calculating what you might do if you found out, and the worst case scenario that she imagined was that you would have a revenge affair. Divorce did not figure in her calculations, because she takes it for granted that you cannot live without her. That is why people keep recommending the 180, going 'dark', and demonstrating that you are not under her control. It is all about liberating you from the subordinate role that your wife has assigned to you in her mind.
The goal of that liberation is to either build a new balance of power within the relationship, in which you become treated as an equal, at which point your wife will start doing the things you need her to do to prove her remorse, or to release you from an unhealthy relationship so that you are no longer treated as a servant, and can meet someone new, who will treat you as an equal.
The OM does not serve your wife or pay for anything, and she admired that and found it attractive. There may be a lesson in that.
I apologise if anything I have written has been painful to read, but it has been written with your best interests at heart. It looks like you have been trying to deal with this from the perspective of a 'love' problem, when to me it seems to be far more about power. I think that things for you as an individual can only be improved if that element is recognised and addressed. Your independence is the key to a better future for you, 36, whether or not it is within the marriage.
[This message edited by M1965 at 3:34 AM, October 12th (Thursday)]