The study presents some interesting findings, although not necessarily the ones being discussed in this thread. Regarding contact with the AP, however, there is an important distinction between "relationship preservation" and "successful reconciliation" that substantially limits the conclusions that can be drawn.
The researchers initially treated remaining together, reconciling, and healing as largely interchangeable outcomes. Their findings demonstrated that this assumption was problematic. I am glad this is Nickerson's study, as that has been a longstanding criticism of mine regarding her advice on YouTube.
One particularly revealing pathway involved continued dishonesty, unanswered questions, failure to block the AP, and the betrayed being blamed for the affair. Despite these circumstances, 88% of the relationships in that subgroup remained intact.
The authors themselves characterized this pathway as potentially pathological, suggesting emotional dependency, power imbalances, and fear of abandonment as possible explanations.
Blocking the AP was identified as a meaningful predictor of relationship preservation. However, some pathways also demonstrated relatively high preservation rates despite continued contact or failure to block the AP.
These findings establish that NC was not a universal prerequisite for remaining together. They do not establish that continued AP contact was compatible with healthy reconciliation.
Another important distinction concerns the interpretation of positive behaviors as compensating for negative ones. The decision tree analysis identified combinations of behaviors associated with different outcomes. It did not establish that reassurance, affection, household contributions, or other positive behaviors causally offset the consequences of continued AP contact.
Failing to block an AP and actively maintaining a relationship with that person are not equivalent behaviors. The study did not adequately distinguish between them or evaluate the quality and circumstances of continued contact.
The betrayed's preferences are also relevant. Continued contact that is mutually understood and accepted represents a substantially different relational arrangement from continued contact that the betrayed experiences as threatening or unacceptable. The study does not provide sufficient evidence to evaluate those circumstances separately.
In my own reconciliation, my wife did not have NC with the AP for the first 21 months. This was because they still worked together, and some contact was necessary for her to perform her job. However, there was transparency regarding the communication that occurred. Now that she has found a new job, that has shifted to blocked/NC.
A more informative study would distinguish couples who simply remain together from those who achieve sustained relationship satisfaction, restored trust, emotional security, and mutual commitment.
Without those distinctions, high relationship preservation rates risk being interpreted as evidence of successful reconciliation, when the study's own findings demonstrate that the two are not necessarily equivalent.