W,
I am glad that your IC went well.
I was thinking over one of your last post about your WW shaming herself at the volunteering place not hiding her relation, there are 5 points that together got me thinking that she was into an exit affair:
1.- What does it mean that she wasn’t hiding it?, I mean to what level, kissing in front of others? Leaving together to his place and co-volunteers covering up for them. Even your Brother caught them holding hands it was at a public place. If I am right you posted before that this was something that not brother had discovered other person would. ?
IMO she was screaming at lout their love to the whole word
2.- The above plus her reaction to OM the few days after Dday, until she saw you in pain, talking to your SIL that she didn’t understand her special relation with OM…
She was/is in love with OM
3.- Her statement that she has been selfish and now she knows that she needs to stop focusing about her and focus on family and you.
She was burring her feelings for OM in order to save her way of life after knowing that OM was a peace of shit.
4.- She used you as an excuse to having an affair, she also pointed out that her affair was not a mistake, was a decision she made.
She was aware of what she was doing.
5.- She pursuing sexual encounters, if it was just about attention she would have been accepting OM sexual advances to get attention not pursuing it, and more since she was aware of everything.
She was/is in love with OM
IMO before knowing that OM was a peace of shit she was trying to decide if a life with OM would be for real and then she saw you ion pain and start to realize the destruction she has done.
Besides the if question that everybody suggested, “What would happen if OM was for real and not a POS ?”, you should also ask her “What would happen if you (W) and your kids were OK with it?”. IMO she thought that it was not a big deal as she was not in love with you and probably you neither, and that the kids will be just fine with her pursuing real love.
Besides the questions about your WW being in love with OM, missing him, grieving for the lost of their relation. You should also ask her if she thought she loved him at that moment as the first question will be answered with what she thinks and thinks she must feel right now. Also ask her if she has resentment for you exposing OM and asking her for NC (I bet she says that now she doesn’t but ask her at the moment after you asked for NC)
She, being a proven layer, never denied or minimized contact with OM after DDay, I may looks like she was getting courage to let you know she was not in love with you anymore.
Be careful with her answers, explain her that wanting to be in love is not that same as being in love, and as you know you can stop loving someone and start loving other one like a switch.
In a nut shell You need to ask her if you are plan B, her safe net when Plan A failed. IMO this is important because if you are Plan B there is always a Plan A out there and maybe next time will be a fine gentleman.
I didn’t mean to hurt you or lead you to D, I am just trying to give you angles to see the whole pic.
Other think, try to keep your cool while talking to her, she needs to feel save to express what she really what to say. Also think at the follow idea, this is based on my experience and unfortunately works as IMO is the fundamental of the 180 technique: THE OPOSITE OF LOVE IS NOT HATE IS INDIFERENCE, the most you wife see you having fun with your kids and brother, being relatively normal around the house she is being hurt of what she is missing (even she was very eager to destroy it) and that hurt the most is that she is no longer a needed peace of it to her family be happy. This apply as well for talk about the time line, if you keep your cool about it she at the beginning will feel safe and thanked to see that she can say it all…with the time will realize that your lack of emotion is not about what she did but about her and it will hurt her like hell…IMO you have being already implementing a kind of 180 technique that at this point is helpful as you haven decide if R or D, but as has been said many times at SI and other webs, in order to save your marriage you will be willing to lose it. Make her clear that you will survive and be happy without her no matter what, that she took you for granted thinking that you will never leave her if find out (if not why she was aware of your agreement about affairs and still in eagerly participating in one if not as an exit affair, contradiction point if come out while talking to her ) and that is not the case anymore if ever was.
Other thing, about your kids. IMO you should discuss what you and she tell your kids if they ask, not just about D but how she and you feel for each other. Your kids don’t need to have false hopes because your wife says that she loves you and will try everything to save her marriage when maybe she just want, and tr6y really hard, to be in love with you but still misses OM or just wants out.
Last thing, you know that here, at SI, you can vent and update anything and anytime but if you feel like you need a break because we are making you paranoid, just do it. As I said before most of us talk from the pain and as much as our experience helps you (especially at this moment) don’t let our words hold you back.
Sorry for the long post and not being clear, English is not my first language.
Good luck.