HowCouldSheDoIt,
Thank you very much for the details, they are incredibly helpful. Unlike your marriage counselor who has become a conspirator in perpetuating abuse upon you. More on that later...
Many details to write, but in general she went on vacation with my adult daughter, met this younger guy at the resort who was staying there alone doing some work in the area. Over the course of two weeks they exchanged texts, flirted by the pool, and one evening he texted "come down to this bar" and it was later and my daughter was asleep, she was feeling depressed about the marriage, was enjoying the attention, and she went.
So she engaged in a reasonably long slow ramp into this. It wasn't as straightforward as a drunken one night stand (again, no offense to those of you betrayed by these means). She gave herself permission to exchange numbers with a man she was attracted to (!). She gave herself permission to meet him alone at a bar (!). She gave herself permission to go back to his room (!). The number of individual times she could have caught herself (already over the line to be honest) and not had sex with him were abundant.
She felt horrible after, and never saw him again and left for home a couple days after. She can't explain why she did it, but knew she needed to tell me, a week later.
If she can't explain why she did it, and why she gave permission to herself multiple times to cross what should have been boundaries, she won't be safe for you again. That's my personal opinion.
She answered all my questions about what happened, and was very open. It was very helpful to my healing but she was very resentful and bitter that I was asking. Probably still is. In MC the therapist scolded me for asking about the details of the sex (which really, really upset me; I have a right to know. Convince me, explain to me, but don't fucking scold me). I agreed that I would not ask for any further details and I haven't.
As foreshadowed at the beginning of this post, I do not approve of this behavior by your MC. You need to fire the MC posthaste. This MC will assist in minimization, rugsweeping, and blameshifting. You are going to get double teamed in emotional abuse. Your WW doesn't care she hurt you, so MC saying "see how he is hurt?" isn't even going to activate her brain cells. Meanwhile, you are going to eat capitulation after capitulation in an attempt to make her happy. Please, please, please don't continue with this MC.
Think about this critically, because your internal reaction is right. How on earth could you be scolded for wanting the truth? How can you forgive what you don't know? You 100% did the right thing to get details, and if you NEED further details, your WW should be willing to give them to you. For your healing to occur, I believe you will have to walk back this agreement. If your WW balks, tell her she walked away a much bigger agreement known to some as "wedding vows".
Fair and agreement are out the window for now. They can be re-established later, but you made that agreement under emotional duress and it simply shouldn't hold.
Look for another MC that specialized in infidelity. The one you are with is inexperienced, over their head, or likely (if you asked) horribly unsuccessful at keeping couples together after adultery.
Even as I write this, I'm still in shock that she would do that. I mean, like she's a totally completely different person than I thought. I have had times when she even looked different, like she resembled my wife, but wasn't her. It's so strange what it does to you.
I believe her that it is over with NC. STD check is clean. She removed his number along with all the texts (I never read them). She promised me she would tell me if he tried to contact her, and he hasn't. She allows me to track her phone so I know where she's at (which is helpful)
It's good that she is NC with him.
Should it be possible with your phone carrier, try to recover the texts. You can also try recovery software, but it seems the OS developers have generally improved text deletion to be true deletion after a pretty short period.
At the very least, get the metadata to see what the text count is. How many messages go back and forth? Did he really text her first about the bar? Pictures?
Confirming her story would go a long way to rebuilding trust if the story actually holds water. There is a world of difference between AP texts at 9:00 first to come down to the bar vs. your WW texts at 8:30 "daughter's asleep and I'm bored". While no WW is "prayed upon", how internally motivated she was to cheat matters as it relates to what kind of boundaries you and she need to establish in the future.
Again, you don't know what your a forgiving if you don't have the details. Other people might disagree with me on this as well. If you think you have enough information, that's all that really matters.
I was very demanding of her, which I regret but that's where I was at. She did not understand triggers at all. For example, she wears a lot of jewelry to bed, which I have always liked when things are jingling and rattling. I insisted that she remove and never wear the jewelry she wore during sex with him. She was offended and refused at first, but ultimately did after I lost my shit about it. I insisted that she remove her wedding ring, which was on the hand that worked his cock. She was offended at this but complied. At first she criticized me and said "what about the underwear or my outfit?" but later came to an understanding and has since put away all reminders.
That's a positive move at least. Removal of affair reminders is the bare minimum to get into recovery.
I have many other examples of treatment from her that aren't exactly horrible, but betray a complete and total cluelessness of what it feels like.
It took my fWW over a year and me asking for divorce several times to understand the damage she did. Anything you do that hides your pain will only extend your timeline for her to understand that you are in fact in a huge amount of pain.
We haven't talked about it in a while, but she used to say that the adultery is not the focus here, the marriage was ruined before the adultery. She objected to me calling it "affair recovery" because the affair is not the only issue. We both agree it isn't the only issue, but we disagree that it is the biggest issue. I would never say this now, but back then I told her that going outside the marriage is worse than anything that happens inside the marriage. No doubt comments like that still stay with her.
My latest thoughts on the matter are the saying "There's no troubled marriage that can't be made worse with adultery."
I think you should deal with the A first, recover from that first. That said, I'm also in the group that believes it is great to put everything on the table and say, "Assuming we can work through the shattered trust stemming from A, is what's left even worth that effort, or should we have D before the A?"
It's a great question, but it can only be answered with "We should D" or "We should figure out how to rebuild trust from the A". Not "Let's work on the M and the A problem will just be magically resolved".
I have been sooooo tempted to have a revenge affair because I wanted to desperately for her to see what it feels like. But I will not be hypocritical and I do still love her and want to stay married. To read my words it might not sound like it, but I do.
You think it's bad now, "There's no troubled marriage that can't be made worse with adultery." :)
I'm against RA's but other people engage in them. I don't think anyone finds them particularly useful at doing anything other than getting revenge and all the damage that goes along with revenge motivated actions.
In therapy she has apologized and asked for forgiveness, and I have made many efforts to make amends for my past behaviors and show change. She is frustrated that I have needed additional assurance and signs that she is sorry. Generally, whenever I indicate that I'm still hurt by the adultery she is cold, defensive and annoyed.
She needs to get WAY over this defensiveness. This is what ate at me for months before we finally reached a common understanding and resolution.
Ok shit that took a long time to write. My lunch break was over like 40 min ago...
I'm multitasking in meetings, thanks COVID.