IMHO too much emphasis in many of the suggestions is on revenge.
Revenge is like urinating on your hands to keep warm in cold weather. It might offer temporary relief but tends to leave you with new and larger problems and even colder after ten minutes or so.
Many have stated you have two paths out of infidelity: R or D. Of the two D is the only one you can decide ALONE to follow. For R you need both parties to want R and to be willing to walk in sync. In my opinion two basics are needed to start reconciliation: there is NC with the AP and there is an openness for being truthful. If you have that then the rest can be worked on along the path to R.
You don’t have either with your wife.
Your wife was in contact after claiming NC. Your wife is not being truthful.
IMHO if you look over your two paths then there is a lot of blockage on R. So much as to question if it’s passable at all. As is then D looks a lot clearer.
The following might turn out to be the BEST advice ever offered on SI:
The absolute WORST advice to get and follow on an online forum is legal advice.
That applies for what I suggest too, so keep that in mind.
Divorce is a two-factored process. There is the emotional separation that you deal with, and there is the legal separation that you get the professionals to do. If you chose to tread on the path of D towards getting out of infidelity then GET A PROFESSIONAL GUIDE.
In other words: Get an attorney.
Some questions you need answers for:
1) Does infidelity factor in divorce in my state and if so then how?
2) What level and type of proof does the court need?
3) Is this that I have here enough or do I need more?
4) If I need more what’s the best way to get it?
5) Can I use the threat of filing due to infidelity to leverage a better settlement for me?
6) Is this separation agreement I have drafted enough? Would it be binding if I file for divorce after she signs?
I encourage you to talk to an attorney and get a CLEAR picture of what D would look like. I get a feeling you have some rosy “I get everything and she get’s nothing” view at the moment, when I think something closer to 50/50 is the real deal. It’s not a bad deal – it beats being in infidelity – but I think it’s always better to have a realistic view on what to expect rather than charge along blindly.
One common misunderstanding is that the two paths – R and D – run in opposite directions. In fact they run parallel for a long time before forking in separate directions. I think there are very few situations where both are totally closed to the BS. It’s only if the WS is determined to remain in infidelity where the BS has no choice but D.
When I discovered my fiancé’s affair I decided to separate. I chose the D path. For me at that time in that relationship it was the best decision. However until I reached that section where D and R no longer run parallel I always had the option to cross over. I decided not to, but when I was wallowing in my misery my logical-brain would sometimes overpower my misery-brain with “You are on the path you chose. You have options. Think the other path is any easier or better?” and I would realize that I was walking the better of two crappy choices.
Sort of like:
"If, therefore, any be unhappy, let him remember that he is unhappy by reason of himself alone."
Can also be turned into:
"If, therefore, any be happy, let him remember that he is happy by reason of himself alone."