Hi everyone -
Good to see you again UB!
To answer your question in short, no it’s not normal.
That said it’s really hard to explain how the whole thing played out.
I’m going to try to give an unrelated made up example:
Everyone is preparing to leave.
SIL goes to shake G5’s hand.
G5 loudly and odiferously passes gas causing SIL to step back and give a questioning look.
G5 apologizes and says he didn’t mean to do that, his belly has just been really bloated.
SIL chuckles and says he wondered when we started communicating with each other that way and leave the house.
My interpretation of SIL’s response was he felt like G5 pulling back from the handshake was a feck you and when G5 apologized that it came off that way SIL chuckled and said yeah well feck you too - he was laughing, and that was it.
To your point, G5 commented that he’s never heard anyone in our family speak to each other that way. Now that I’m thinking about it, I wish I would have said that no one in our family also doesn’t hug each other or refuses to shake hands, but you expect my family to accept that behavior from you and not feel any sort of way about it.
You know, like when someone does something that seems really off the wall and you’re like when did we start doing THAT? They say oh no, no, no and then you respond with what your response would have been to that perceived situation.
My lord did that make sense at all??
I should couple this with my observation that G5 has conflict with more people than anyone else I’ve ever met in my entire life. He got into a shouting match with a woman at our local casino over who was going to sit in this certain spot - the dealer intervened, other people at the table were trying to diffuse it, etc. So I guess when I see him getting into conflict with people that generally seems out of proportion to the situation everything comes in through that filter, including the incident with SIL. It’s definitely something I will be bringing up. (High conflict)
My issue isn’t that I think he shouldn’t be upset, it’s that his chosen method of handling it (silent treatment) is unhealthy and in and of itself emotionally abusive. When I found out he was upset (months later) I was ready and willing to get on the phone and say something and work toward restoring peace. He did not want me to do that and instead has just held the emotions of everyone else that cares about the situation hostage over it.
This is a problem for me.
Something else that has been bothering me (and the list is getting longer as I start to unpack all of this), is that I don’t like that he was willing to take the gamble of breaking up with me, assuming that I would take him back. Maybe I’m reaching on that one just because I’m pissed off.
I got the five love languages from the library. They are holding it and I’ll pick up tomorrow.
To his credit he has been willing to do anything that I have asked so far. This week we took the apology languages quiz online and shared our results with each other.
Something I’m concerned about in the big picture is I’m afraid our core values surrounding family may be really out of alignment. I thought it was a matter of him not feeling comfortable with them and I thought it was getting better, but I’m back to feeling like I’m begging him to participate in family things that I would be bending over backwards to accommodate for any of our kids.
There’s also a lack of empathy for certain situations, but I think that may be a learning point or self awareness - aka I don’t think he realizes he comes off the way he does.
Whew. I hope this isn’t a jumbled mess. It feels jumbled in my head.
Thanks for listening and I appreciate everyone’s feedback!