Planc - Her words say reconcilation. Her actions until lately said divorce. Trust is beyond non-existant though.
Tren0R201 - My affair was from spite. In short, I didn't get much other than to know that there are other fish in the sea. I did get the feeling of being desired after feeling like I was tossed aside. There wasn't really a doubt about that but experience teaches you something. I felt guilty the whole time even though I felt that I had every right to that affair. Makes it so much harder to understand hers.
gonnabegr8 - It's harder to look at the haves vs have nots right now. You're right.
Loukas - Win/Lose is just one way that I find myself looking at it. We each pay a price no matter what. Hard for me to stomach it though, unlike a natural disaster which just "happens" this happened because of the choice my WW made. I have to pay a price no matter what, she chose to pay that price. Whether she knew it at the time or not, it was her choice to make. She also made that choice twice even after seeing the cost the first time.
Staying
She: Loses nothing, no compromises besides transparency (soft choice) which is a both an act and a decision to share, she's expected to make me comforable with her actions. Gains: The life she had before without consequence or real compromise. Her self-respect and self-esteem are restored by my willingness to accept it and move forward with her.
Me: Loses - Compromise self-respect (which should be a limited time ), Trust (lots of it), Never being able to fully-commit again in this relationship. I will never be able to be able to say to another living soul how proud I am to have her as my wife. Gains: Nothing but the life I had before, best outcome is somehow my relationship is better. That seems like a long-term goal though, years. I haven't seen too many "success stories" on SI though.
Leaving:
She: Loses dignity and self-respect, (some) financial security, short-term (a partner who loves her), some time with our child. Family is broken. Gains: Nothing? Except maybe she is too much of a coward to admit she doesn't want to be with me.
Me: Loses more time with our child (she won't budge on this), financial stability (costs me to leave her and stay gone, I then also need to provide for myself entirely), Gains: self-worth and respect. A chance at a life with someone who won't do this to me again (3rd times the charm?)
My costs (not financial) are higher in every case .
About me prior to meeting her, I had come out of a 4-year relationship with a girlfriend who I suspected but never caught cheating on me. All the signs were there but she was too good at covering it up. My WW seemed like the polar opposite in every aspect. I didn't recover from that 4-year relationship very well either, I left that girlfriend on suspicion alone. The actual break-up took a lot of back and forth of breaking up and reconciling over several months. Just after that I went on a handful of dates that wouldn't get past a first date.
What was broken in me then was lack of love in general and trust for another person. My parents didn't show it in childhood. I got it from my grandparents mainly which made my relationship sort of weird with my parents. After this relationsip I lost the feeling of love and safety that the relationship had given me. Over time I was able to trust myself, rely on myself and acknowledge that I was worthy of someone elses love by realizing that I gained self-respect by leaving that girlfriend. Not knowing for sure then made me nuts... However knowing I'd never be comfortable around her was enough to go and then it took time for me to recover emotionally.
My WW has proven through her acts that she has the capacity to do the most despicable things. She gaslit me for months and I begam doubting myself. I honestly felt like I had absolutelty lost it. I wanted to trust her so bad but for months she made me doubt common sense and my instincts. She'd habitually say something and then claim she never said it or that she meant something else. She tried to convince me that for three months she never saw her COW/AP in the office whom she was seeing routinely for months prior. She'd deliberately say things in a way to lead me to a conclusion but there would be a lie buried. Her: "I told you that I spoke with him after you called his wife". Without asking, I assumed after meant the same day, hours. After turns out to be several days after. That comes to light at a later time. I'd later find out from an IC that this is gaslighting.
My WW stole all of that safety, comfort with this affair and her inability to tell me anything without an interrogation. I don't feel that she loses quite as much given any outcome. This crap will haunt me whether with her or someone else. It's happened to me twice now.
I cheated, it would never have happened if she didn't first. There is no relief of vindication in that act. It created more problems than it solved. I screwed with someone elses emotions out of spite for my wife. I couldn't parse out which feelings of mine were real vs not in my experiences with my AP. While painful for my WW to endure, there was no shock and awe aspect for her. It did not come from out of thin air. I don't expect this will create lasting trust issues for her. I came clean quickly and disclosed all details without needing them pulled from me. The same is not true for her.